Spotlight

Chapter 7: The Man Who Had Been Watching

I didn't answer immediately.

I pressed the phone against my ear and looked at Michael and mouthed one word: *recording.*

He already had his own phone out, screen open to a voice memo app.

He held it toward mine.

"Who is this?" I asked.

"Someone who has known your name for a very long time." The voice was relaxed.

The kind of relaxed that comes from having made decisions and already being at peace with them.

"Your father spoke about you often, back when we were still speaking."

"Gerald Marsh," I said.

A short pause.

"He told you about me."

"He didn't need to.

I found the document."

The pause this time was longer.

"I see."

"Twelve pages.

His handwriting in the margins.

Names, dates, transfer records.

And a note at the bottom saying copies exist elsewhere."

"Copies that have never surfaced in thirteen years," Marsh said.

"Which should tell you something about how much danger they actually represent."

"Or it tells me he hid them somewhere you've never found."

"Rebecca." His voice didn't change.

That was the frightening part.

"I want you to understand something clearly.

I have no interest in harming your family.

I never did.

The arrangement your father and I reached was mutually beneficial.

He got his freedom.

I got my privacy.

Everyone moved on."

"I didn't move on," I said.

"I was nineteen years old and I dropped out of college and worked two jobs for thirteen years because everyone told me my parents were g*ne."

"That was your father's choice.

Not mine."

The calmness of it was worse than anger would have been.

"What do you want?" I asked.

"I want that document," Marsh said.

"And I want your word that whatever your brother told you tonight stays in that kitchen." Another pause.

"In exchange, I'll tell you something your father never did.

Something I think you deserve to know."

Michael was shaking his head across the table.

His lips formed the word *no.*

"And if I say no?" I asked.

"Then I think things become more complicated for everyone involved." He said it gently.

The way someone says *it might rain tomorrow.* "Your father made a choice that protected him.

I'd prefer you to have the same option."

"That sounds like a threat."

"It's a reality." He let it sit for a moment.

"Think about your siblings, Rebecca.

You've spent thirteen years protecting them.

I'd encourage you to continue doing so."

Michael stood up from his chair.

His jaw was rigid.

"I'll need time," I said.

"Of course.

I'll call again in twenty-four hours." A brief pause.

"Oh — and I'd recommend against contacting law enforcement.

Paul Garrett will know immediately if you do.

And so will I."

The call ended.

I set the phone down on the table face-up.

Michael reached over and stopped the recording on his phone.

We looked at each other.

"He wants the document," Michael said.

"He wants us scared.

The document is secondary." I picked up the folder and held it.

"He's been sitting on this for thirteen years.

He wouldn't have let Dad keep the original unless he believed it could never be traced back to him without the copies.

And the copies—"

"The note said copies held separately," Michael said slowly.

"Rebecca.

What if Dad sent them somewhere before he left?"

I had been turning the same thought over since we'd read the document the first time.

"The day before they disappeared," I said.

"Do you remember?

Dad mailed something.

I saw him at the mailbox early in the morning.

I thought it was a bill."

"I remember," Michael said.

"You mentioned it to the search coordinator."

"And they said it was irrelevant." I set the folder down.

"What if it wasn't a bill?

What if he mailed the copies to someone he trusted?

Someone Marsh would never think to look at?"

Michael went very still.

"He had a sister," he said.

"Aunt Carol.

She moved to Vermont years before we were born.

I haven't thought about her in—"

"I have her address," I said.

He looked at me.

"It's in the box.

On a Christmas card from before the disappearance." I was already moving back toward the attic stairs.

"Michael.

If Dad mailed those copies to Carol and they've been sitting in Vermont for thirteen years—"

"Then we have everything Marsh is afraid of."

"And everything we need." I stopped at the foot of the stairs.

May you like

"We're not giving him that document.

And we're not waiting twenty-four hours."

Related Stories

Other posts