Chapter 6: What Was in the Attic Box

The document was in a manila folder inside a shoebox inside a larger cardboard box that had been taped shut since the year we lost the house.
I had moved it three times in thirteen years — from a friend's garage to a storage unit to my attic — without ever opening it.
I cut the tape with a kitchen knife while Michael stood in the attic doorway with his phone flashlight aimed at the box.
"I almost threw it away twice," I said.
"I told myself it was just old bills and school records.
I couldn't stand going through it.
Every time I tried, I felt like I was going through a g*ne person's things."
"They let you believe that," Michael said.
There was no anger in his voice.
Just something flat and tired.
"Yes."
The folder was near the bottom, beneath a stack of utility bills and two of our childhood school photos still in their paper envelopes.
I lifted it out and carried it down to the kitchen table.
Inside was a single document, twelve pages, printed on heavy paper.
Some pages had handwritten annotations in the margins.
My father's pen.
That same hard-pressing, ridge-leaving hand.
Michael sat across from me and we read it together.
It took twenty minutes.
Neither of us spoke while we read.
The document was a financial agreement between my father and Gerald Marsh, dated sixteen years ago — three years before the disappearance.
On the surface it described a joint investment arrangement.
But my father's handwritten notes in the margins told a different story, page by page.
Specific dates.
Specific dollar amounts.
Specific names of clients whose money had been redirected without their knowledge.
And at the bottom of the final page, a single line in my father's hand: *GM instructed all transfers.
Records attached.
Copies held separately.*
"The copies," I said.
"He says copies are held separately."
"Where?"
"I don't know.
This is the original.
But he knew this wasn't safe enough on its own." I turned to the last annotated page.
"He was building a case against Gerald Marsh.
That's what this is.
This isn't a business record.
It's evidence."
Michael sat back in his chair.
He pressed both hands over his face and held them there for a moment.
"Dad was going to expose him," he said from behind his hands.
"I think Gerald Marsh found out before he could."
He dropped his hands.
"And instead of turning Dad over to the authorities and risking the evidence coming to light — he gave Dad a way out.
Leave.
Disappear.
Take your wife and go.
And the evidence stays buried."
"And Dad took the deal."
"Because he was scared.
And because—" Michael stopped.
"Because the alternative was worse," I said.
We looked at each other across the table with the document between us.
"He left us," I said.
The words came out without weight, without drama.
Just the fact of them.
"He left eight children behind to protect himself from consequences he had brought on."
"And to protect us too, maybe."
"Don't," I said quietly.
Michael didn't finish the thought.
I turned back to the document.
"Gerald Marsh has spent thirteen years believing this evidence is either g*ne or buried deep enough not to matter.
If Paul Garrett — whoever he really is — reports back that I've been asking questions, Marsh will start to worry.
And if he starts to worry—"
My phone buzzed on the table.
A regular call.
Unknown number.
I looked at Michael.
He gave a small shake of his head.
I answered it anyway.
The voice on the other end was unhurried.
Male.
Older.
"Rebecca," the voice said.
May you like
"I think it's time we talked.
Don't you?"