Spotlight

Chapter 5: The Name Our Father Never Explained

We sat with the phone between us for a long moment.

Neither of us touched it.

"Who sent that?" I asked.

"I don't know the number."

"Can you call it back?"

He picked up the phone and pressed the number.

We both listened.

It rang twice.

Then a recorded voice told us the number was no longer in service.

Burner phone.

Gone the moment the message was sent.

I pulled my chair around to Michael's side of the table and sat next to him instead of across from him.

Something about the text had changed the geometry of the room.

We were no longer facing each other.

We were looking at the same problem from the same direction.

"She already knows," I said.

"Who is she?"

"I don't know."

"Could it be Mom?"

Michael thought about it.

"Mom doesn't — she wouldn't phrase it that way.

And she doesn't have my number.

I always called them from a prepaid phone I kept separate.

She couldn't have sent it from a different number."

"Then someone else knows you were coming here tonight."

"Or someone knows you've been asking questions," he said.

"Rebecca, have you talked to anyone about our parents?

Recently?

Anyone at all?"

I thought.

"Three months ago I hired a private investigator.

Just to see if there was anything new.

Any trail that had gone cold." I paused.

"He came back with nothing.

Said there was no record of them after the search ended."

Michael went very still.

"Who was he?"

"A local firm.

I found them online.

They seemed legitimate." I looked at him.

"His name was Paul Garrett."

The silence that followed was different from all the silences before it.

"Garrett," Michael said.

"Yes."

"That was the name in the voicemail."

My mouth was dry.

"I know."

"Rebecca." He turned to face me fully.

"What exactly did you tell Paul Garrett?"

"Everything I knew.

Which was almost nothing.

The original disappearance, the search, the presumed d*ath ruling.

The years of trying to find any record of them afterward." I stopped.

"He asked me if I had any siblings who might have information.

I said yes.

I gave him your name."

Michael closed his eyes.

"I'm sorry," I said.

"I didn't know.

I had no reason to think—"

"It's not your fault." He opened his eyes.

"But Paul Garrett wasn't a private investigator.

Or he wasn't only that." He pointed at the phone.

"Someone had eyes on this conversation tonight the moment it started.

Maybe before."

"Gerald Marsh sent someone to watch me."

"I think Gerald Marsh sent someone to watch both of us." He stood up and walked to my kitchen window.

He stayed to the side of the glass, not in front of it.

"And now that person has reported back that you know what I told you tonight.

That's what the text means.

Not a warning to us.

A report to someone else."

"Our phones," I said.

He was already nodding.

"Don't say anything on this phone you don't want heard."

I looked around my kitchen.

My ordinary kitchen with its linoleum floor and the coffee maker and the dish towel hanging through the oven handle the way it always did and the photograph on the refrigerator — all seven siblings at Christmas, eight years ago, Michael standing behind me with his hand on my shoulder.

"I need to call someone," I said.

"Not on that phone."

"Then I need to get a different phone."

"Tonight?"

"Tonight." I stood up and grabbed my jacket from the hook by the door.

"And then I need to tell you something I should have said the moment you sat down."

He looked at me across the kitchen.

"I found something three weeks ago," I said.

"In a box I'd been keeping in the attic since we lost the house.

Dad's papers.

Things I packed up and never went through properly because I couldn't face it." I picked up my keys.

"There's a document in that box, Michael.

A legal document.

And if what you've told me tonight is true — if Dad left on purpose and Gerald Marsh knows our family's name — then that document changes everything about why they ran."

His jaw was set.

"What kind of document?"

I looked at him for a moment.

At my brother, who had been seventeen years old and terrified and alone with a secret that should never have been his to carry.

"One that proves Dad didn't owe Gerald Marsh money," I said.

"It proves the opposite.

Gerald Marsh owed Dad — and Dad had evidence of exactly what that debt was for."

Michael's hand dropped from the window frame.

"They didn't run because Dad was in trouble," I said quietly.

May you like

"They ran because Dad had proof that could put Gerald Marsh away.

And Gerald Marsh has spent thirteen years making sure no one ever finds it."

Related Stories

Other posts