Chapter 4: The Call That Started Everything Over Again

I sat back down.
"What did he say?"
Michael pulled out his phone.
His hands were steadier than mine.
He scrolled, found something, and turned the screen to face me.
It was a voicemail transcript.
The app had converted the audio to text, imperfectly, the way those things always do — a few words replaced with phonetic guesses, punctuation missing.
But the meaning was clear enough.
*Michael it's Dad.
I need you to listen carefully.
Things have gotten complicated again.
The arrangement we had — it's over.
Someone has been asking questions.
I don't know how they found us but they have been asking questions about the family.
About Rebecca specifically.
I need you to warn her.
Tell her not to—*
The transcript ended there.
Mid-sentence.
I stared at the screen.
"When did this come in?"
"Six days ago."
"And you waited six days."
"I needed to think.
I needed to figure out how to tell you everything first without you—" He stopped.
"Without me what?"
"Without you going straight to the police."
I set the phone down on the table between us.
"And why would that be a problem, Michael?"
He rubbed his face with both hands.
"Because if the wrong people find out we talked to law enforcement, Dad said the arrangement collapses completely.
And whatever protection he has disappears with it."
"He said that in the voicemail?"
"He said it when he called before.
A few years ago." Michael dropped his hands.
"Rebecca, I know how this sounds.
I know how all of it sounds.
But Dad was genuinely frightened.
I haven't heard him sound like that since—" He stopped again.
"Since when?"
"Since the night before they left."
The cat across the street had moved.
The neighbor's porch light was on now.
Small details.
I noticed them because my mind was trying to hold onto something ordinary while everything underneath it shifted.
"Someone has been asking questions about me specifically," I said.
"That's what he said."
"Do you have any idea who?"
"No." Michael hesitated.
One second too long.
"Michael."
"There was a name.
In the voicemail.
The app didn't catch it right.
It came out as gibberish." He reached across and tapped the screen, scrolling back up to a section I had skimmed.
Near the top, where the transcript had produced a string of letters that meant nothing.
"I played the audio back four times," he said.
"It sounded like — Garrett.
Or Gerald.
Something with a G."
I went very still.
"Does that mean something to you?" he asked.
I looked at the string of garbled letters on the screen.
Then I looked at my brother.
"Our father had a business partner," I said.
"Before everything fell apart.
I was maybe sixteen.
The man came to the house twice for dinner.
Mom always got quiet when he was there." I paused.
"His name was Gerald Marsh."
Michael stared at me.
"I remembered him because of the way he looked at the house when he left the second time.
Like he was calculating something." I stood up and walked to the counter.
My coffee cup was still there from earlier in the evening, cold now.
I wrapped both hands around it anyway.
"Dad told me he was just a business associate.
He never mentioned him again after that."
"Do you know what kind of business?"
"No.
I was sixteen and I was more worried about whether we'd have enough money for school supplies." I set the cup down.
"But if Gerald Marsh is the one who made the original arrangement — if he's the one who called you when you were seventeen—"
"Then someone has been asking him questions," Michael said slowly, "and he's trying to find out if the loose ends are still tied."
The word *loose ends* landed badly.
We both heard it.
"He used that phrase," I said.
"In the voicemail."
Michael nodded.
"Near the end.
Where the transcript cuts off.
He said — *make sure the loose ends are—* and then the message ended."
I turned around and faced my brother directly.
"Michael.
Is there anything else you haven't told me?
Anything at all.
Because I need to know the full picture before I decide what to do next.
All of it.
Right now."
He opened his mouth.
His phone lit up on the table between us.
Not a call.
A text.
He glanced down at it and the color left his face in a way that made my stomach drop.
He turned the screen so I could read it.
May you like
Three words, from a number he didn't have saved.
*She already knows.*