Spotlight

Chapter 5: The Woman in the Photograph

I waited until the patrol cars left, then locked myself in the guest room with my laptop.

Toby struck the door twice with his palm.

“Open this door.”

“Tell me why Lena warned me about you.”

“She didn’t.

Kelsie sent that message.”

“Then explain the photograph.”

“I already did.”

“You called an eight-year marriage a few months of dating.”

The handle turned, but I had pushed a chair beneath it.

Toby’s voice softened.

“Mara, you’re tired.

Kelsie planned this because she wants the house.”

“Was Lena your wife when you met me?”

Silence answered first.

“Toby?”

“Yes.”

The single word made my hands fall from the keyboard.

“You told me I was your first wife.”

“I thought Lena was gone for good.”

“You thought that made lying acceptable?”

“I needed your credit to refinance this house.”

The chair scraped as I leaned against it.

“So that was why you married me?”

“Don’t make it sound ugly.”

“You just said you needed my credit.”

“And you needed someone after your mother passed.

We helped each other.”

My breath caught.

He had taken the loneliest year of my life and placed a price on it.

“Open the door,” he said.

“Sign the refinance papers tomorrow, and we can fix this.”

I wiped my face.

“There will be no refinance.”

“Then the bank could take everything.”

“Let it.”

“You’ll lose your savings.”

“I’d rather lose money than spend another night beside a stranger.”

His footsteps retreated.

A minute later, the front door closed and his car started.

I called the number from the message.

Kelsie answered.

“Mara?”

“He’s gone.”

“I’m coming over.”

“The order—”

“I’ll stay on the sidewalk.

You come to me.”

When I stepped outside, Kelsie stood beneath the streetlight holding a thermos and a set of keys.

“You should hate me for painting your door,” she said.

“I haven’t decided yet.”

“That’s fair.” She poured tea into the thermos lid.

“Drink this.

Your hands are shaking.”

I took it, and the warmth against my fingers nearly undid me.

“Kelsie, why didn’t you simply knock?”

“I did, twice.

Toby answered both times.

Then he filed that order and told the police I was obsessed.”

She held up a small brass key.

“Lena said this opens the blue box.”

“Can I speak to her?”

Kelsie made a video call.

A woman appeared on the screen with the same eyes as the woman in the photograph.

“Mara,” she said.

“I’m sorry we met this way.”

“Are you Lena?”

“Yes.”

“Did Toby forge the deed?”

“Yes.

I discovered it after an accident left me dependent on him.

When I confronted him, he told everyone my memory was failing.”

Kelsie’s eyes filled.

“I believed him at first.”

Lena looked at her sister.

“Say the rest.”

Kelsie’s voice cracked.

“I signed papers saying Lena needed supervised care.

Toby told me it would protect her.

Instead, it helped him control her money.”

Lena reached toward the camera.

“You made a terrible mistake.

Then you spent eleven years trying to find me.”

Kelsie covered her mouth, and I placed an arm around her shoulders.

“I nearly gave up,” she whispered.

“But you didn’t,” Lena said.

We stood together beneath the streetlight, three women joined by one man’s lies.

“Where is Toby now?” Lena asked.

“I don’t know,” I said.

“Then don’t wait.

Open the north wall.”

Delia returned off duty and watched from the driveway while Kelsie and I removed a loose sheet of paneling.

Behind it sat a narrow blue metal box.

The brass key turned.

Kelsie lifted the lid.

There were no documents inside.

Only a fresh white envelope bearing my name.

I opened it with trembling fingers.

May you like

Inside, in Toby’s handwriting, were four words:

YOU’RE TOO LATE, MARA.

Related Stories

Other posts