Chapter 3: The Name Toby Buried

The black paint slid down the white panels in slow streaks.
Underneath it, thin blue letters appeared one by one.
KELSIE — NORTH WALL — BLUE BOX.
“What does that mean?” I asked.
“Nothing,” Toby said.
“She painted those words herself.”
Kelsie shook her head.
“That writing has been under your white paint for eleven years.”
“You expect Mara to believe that?”
It was the first time either of them had said my name, but they spoke as if I were not standing there.
I held up the photograph.
“Who is the woman beside you?”
Toby reached for it.
I pulled it against my chest.
“Kelsie’s sister,” he said.
“Her name was Lena.
We dated years ago.”
Kelsie’s mouth tightened.
“You married her.”
I turned to him.
“You told me you’d never been married.”
“It was a private ceremony.
It lasted a few months.”
“Eight years,” Kelsie said.
Toby pointed at her.
“Get off my property.”
“Her property,” Kelsie replied.
“Lena inherited this house from our father.”
Toby laughed, but his eyes stayed on the garage door.
“Lena sold it to me.”
“No, she didn’t.”
“I have the deed.”
“And Lena left proof that you forged it.”
Toby’s smile disappeared.
I looked from the words to the north wall of the garage.
“What’s in the blue box?”
Kelsie stepped toward me.
“Letters, the original deed, and a recording.
Lena hid them before she left.”
“Left where?”
Kelsie swallowed.
“That’s the question Toby never wanted anyone to ask.”
Toby seized the garden hose and turned it on.
Water struck the door, sending black paint across the driveway.
“What are you doing?” I shouted.
“Cleaning up her vandalism.”
Kelsie moved in front of the door.
“The lettering is oil enamel.
Water won’t remove it.”
“Move.”
“No.”
He dropped the hose and reached for the garage handle.
Kelsie grabbed his wrist.
“Toby, don’t.”
“Take your hands off me.”
I stepped between them.
“Both of you, stop.
We’re opening that wall.”
Toby stared at me.
“Mara, go inside.”
“No.”
“I said go inside.”
“And I said we’re opening the wall.”
For one second, nobody moved.
Then Toby gave me a look I had never seen in twelve years of marriage.
“If you tear into that wall,” he said softly, “you will regret it.”
Kelsie lifted her chin.
“There he is.
That’s the man my sister knew.”
Toby pulled out his phone.
“I’m calling the police.”
“Call them,” I said.
“I have the security footage.”
His thumb stopped above the screen.
Kelsie looked at the camera beneath the roofline.
“It recorded all of this?”
“It uploads automatically.”
Toby turned toward me.
“Give me your phone.”
“No.”
“Mara, she’s been trespassing.
That video is evidence.”
“Then the police can see it.”
He stepped closer.
“Give it to me.”
Kelsie moved beside me.
“Don’t let him touch it.”
Toby lunged, snatched the phone from my hand, and threw it onto the driveway.
The screen cracked beneath his heel.
I stared down at the broken glass.
“You just destroyed my phone.”
“It slipped.”
Kelsie pointed at the camera.
“That recorded you too.”
A red light blinked beneath the roofline.
Toby looked up at it, then slowly turned back to us.
May you like
“You recorded me?” he whispered.
Before I could answer, blue lights swept across the front of our house.