Chapter 4: The Warning Toby Couldn’t Erase

Two officers stepped from the patrol car.
Toby raised both hands and walked toward them.
“Thank goodness,” he said.
“My neighbor has been vandalizing our home.”
Kelsie did not run.
She placed the roller on the ground and stood beside me.
One officer, a silver-haired woman named Delia, looked at the paint.
“Who owns the property?”
“My husband and I do,” I said.
“Kelsie claims her sister owns it,” Toby added.
“She’s been harassing us for years.”
“That’s not true,” Kelsie said.
“Ask him why he took out a restraining order two days before I painted the door.”
Delia turned to Toby.
“You expected her to come here?”
Toby’s jaw tightened.
“She sent threatening letters.”
“I sent Mara two letters,” Kelsie said.
“Neither contained a threat.”
I looked at her.
“I never received them.”
Toby answered before she could.
“Because I threw them away.
They were nonsense.”
“You opened mail addressed to me?”
“We’re married.”
“That wasn’t my question.”
The second officer examined the writing beneath the paint.
Delia held out her hand to Kelsie.
“Do you have identification?”
“Yes.” Kelsie handed it over.
“I also have a letter from Lena explaining how to reveal those words.”
Toby laughed.
“Lena hasn’t been seen in eleven years.”
“She has now.”
Toby’s face lost its color.
I caught his sleeve.
“What does that mean?”
Kelsie looked directly at me.
“My sister is alive.”
My knees weakened, and Delia caught my elbow.
Toby shook his head.
“This is a trick.
Lena disappeared after taking money from me.”
“She disappeared because she was frightened of you,” Kelsie said.
“Enough.”
“No, Toby.
You’ve had eleven years of silence.”
Delia unfolded the letter inside Kelsie’s pocket envelope.
“This is dated six weeks ago.”
“She could have written it herself,” Toby said.
“The signature was witnessed at Rosewood Recovery Residence,” Kelsie replied.
“Call them.”
Toby moved toward the garage.
“There is no blue box.
I renovated that wall years ago.”
“You told me the garage had never been remodeled,” I said.
He stopped.
Delia studied him.
“Sir, step away from the building.”
“It’s my garage.”
“At the moment, ownership appears disputed.”
Toby pulled a folded document from his robe pocket.
“Here.
The deed is in my name.”
Kelsie stared at it.
“Why were you carrying that at two-thirty in the morning?”
“I heard shouting and grabbed the first relevant document.”
“You slept with the deed in your robe?”
Toby thrust it toward Delia.
“She’s unstable.
Remove her.”
For a moment, it seemed to work.
The second officer asked Kelsie to turn around while he checked the restraining order.
Toby leaned toward me.
“Go inside, Mara.
I’ll handle this.”
“You’ve handled enough.”
His fingers closed around my arm.
Delia looked down at them.
“Let her go.”
Toby released me.
“I was comforting my wife.”
“No,” I said.
“You were trying to control where I stood.”
Kelsie was escorted toward the patrol car because the order prohibited her from coming within fifty feet of our house.
Toby watched with a faint smile.
“You see?” he said.
“This is over.”
Delia waited until the other officer was speaking with Kelsie.
Then she placed a card in my palm.
“Her order is valid,” she said quietly.
“But it was filed using claims we haven’t verified.”
“Are you taking her away?”
“We’re removing her from the property.
That is not the same as believing your husband.”
Toby called from the porch.
“Mara!”
Delia lowered her voice.
“Your camera footage should be in the cloud.
Change the password before anyone else reaches it.”
My broken phone buzzed weakly on the driveway.
The cracked screen lit with a message from an unknown number.
DO NOT OPEN THE WALL WHILE TOBY IS IN THE HOUSE.
May you like
A second message appeared.
HE ALREADY KNOWS LENA IS ALIVE.