Spotlight

Chapter 8: The Deposition

Garrett Moss requested mediation.

Helen declined.

His office responded with a formal demand for a deposition.

Helen accepted that one.

She wanted Moss in a room with a transcript running.

The deposition was scheduled for a Thursday.

A conference room in a building downtown.

Helen on my side of the table.

Moss on the other, with Sandra beside him in a grey jacket, her hands folded in front of her like she was attending a board meeting.

Diane was not present.

Helen had noted that in advance as a strategic choice by Moss — keep the most volatile element out of the room.

Moss began with the loan agreement.

Walked through it methodically.

Sandra's claim.

The legal transfer of collateral rights.

The validity of the original document.

Helen let him run.

Then she placed a single photograph on the table.

A printout of the email.

The one with the date.

The one with the prognosis.

"Ms.

Holloway," Helen said, "in this email dated fourteen months before Mr.

Vance — Nora's father — formally consulted you about a loan, you reference a medical prognosis for his wife.

My client's mother." She slid the email across.

"Can you explain how you came to have that information?"

Sandra looked at the email.

Then at Moss.

Moss put his hand on the table.

"We're here to discuss the property claim —"

"The property claim rests on the validity of a transaction," Helen said pleasantly.

"The validity of that transaction depends on whether it was entered into freely and without undue influence.

If Ms.

Holloway was cultivating a relationship with Mr.

Vance during his wife's terminal illness — using knowledge she had no legitimate means of obtaining — that is directly material to the nature of this transaction." She looked at Sandra.

"Ms.

Holloway.

How did you know?"

Sandra's hands, still folded.

"I don't recall the specific context of that email."

"You don't recall."

"Conversations happen.

People share things."

"Who shared this with you?"

A pause.

"I don't recall."

Helen picked up the recorder.

She set it on the table between them.

She pressed play.

Sandra's voice filled the room.

Clear.

Unhurried.

Eleven years old and perfectly preserved.

*Push the collateral claim the moment she lists.

Structure it as a routine dispute — she won't have the resources to fight it at that stage.

We've done this before, Garrett.

You know how it moves.*

The recording ran for forty seconds.

Helen stopped it.

Moss's expression did not change.

But his right hand moved from the table to his lap.

"That recording," he said carefully, "was ruled inadmissible in a prior proceeding."

"In a prior civil proceeding in a different jurisdiction involving a different party," Helen said.

"We are not in that proceeding.

We are in this one." She folded her hands.

"And the prior proceeding is itself now the subject of a pattern-of-conduct review.

Which means admissibility will be evaluated in an entirely different context." She looked at Moss, not at Sandra.

"I think you know what that means, Garrett."

Something in Moss's posture shifted.

Nearly invisible.

But I saw it.

Sandra turned her head slightly and looked at Moss directly.

"Say something," she said quietly.

Moss did not say something.

He looked at his notes.

He picked up a pen.

He set it back down.

"We could take a short recess," he said.

"Of course," Helen said.

She was entirely pleasant about it.

---

The recess lasted twenty-two minutes.

When Moss came back in, he sat down and placed a single sheet of paper on the table.

"My client is prepared to withdraw her collateral claim in full," he said.

"In exchange for a release of all civil claims arising from —"

"No release," Helen said.

Moss looked up.

"She withdraws the claim," Helen said.

"Unconditionally.

In writing.

Notarized today.

Any civil or criminal referrals arising from the evidence in our possession proceed independently and are not subject to negotiation." She picked up her pen.

"Those are the terms."

Sandra made a sound.

Not quite a word.

More like something escaping.

"Garrett," Sandra said.

Her voice had changed.

The careful neutrality was gone.

"You told me this was airtight."

Moss looked at the paper in front of him.

"Garrett."

He didn't look at her.

He picked up his pen and initialed the withdrawal form.

Sandra's chair scraped back from the table.

She stood.

She looked at me across the table — and for just a moment the performance dropped entirely, and what was underneath it was not rage or grief but something much smaller.

"You should have just taken the settlement," she said.

"So should Carol Venn," I said.

Sandra walked out.

The door closed.

Helen capped her pen.

"That went slightly better than expected."

I looked at the withdrawal form sitting on the table between us.

My mother's house.

My house.

"Is it over?" I asked.

"The property claim is over," Helen said.

"The fraud referral goes to the DA's office next week.

And the medical information leak — I have a contact in the hospital's compliance department who is very interested in that question." She stood and began stacking her papers.

"So no.

It's not completely over.

But the part that was yours to fight?

You fought it."

May you like

I sat for a moment after she started packing up.

Then I picked up my bag and stood.

Related Stories

Other posts