Spotlight

Chapter 4: The First Wife Wasn't My Mother

Her name was Carol Venn.

She had been Sandra's first husband's business partner's wife — that was how the connection ran, buried three links deep, the kind of connection that looks accidental until you realize nothing about Sandra Holloway was accidental.

Carol Venn had lost her house eleven years ago.

A collateral dispute.

A loan signed during a difficult period.

A legal claim that materialized the moment Carol's husband tried to sell.

I found the court filing at half past midnight.

I printed it and set it on my kitchen table next to my coffee cup.

The attorney on Sandra's side, eleven years ago, was a man named Garrett Moss.

I looked up Garrett Moss.

He was still practicing.

And according to the bar association directory, his office was forty minutes from where I was sitting.

I went to bed at one in the morning.

I didn't sleep well.

But I slept enough.

My father arrived at eight fifteen.

He had a manila envelope in his hand and the look of a man who had been awake longer than I had.

I let him in.

This time, I made coffee.

Not because I'd forgiven him.

Because I needed him functional.

"Everything I have," he said, setting the envelope on the table.

I opened it while he watched.

The loan agreement was four pages.

Sandra's signature was clean and confident.

My father's was slightly uneven — the signature of someone signing under pressure, or grief, or both.

The date confirmed what he'd told me.

Six weeks before my mother passed.

"Did she approach you, or did you approach her?" I asked, without looking up.

"She offered," he said.

"I was at the end of my rope.

The business creditors were threatening to move fast.

She said she could help.

She said it was just a formality.

That she'd never collect on it."

"And you believed her."

Silence.

"Dad."

"I was scared.

And she was kind to me at a time when I didn't know how to ask anyone else for help."

I set down the document.

"She was already involved with you when Mom was alive.

Wasn't she."

He didn't answer.

That was the answer.

I slid the loan agreement back into the envelope.

"Her attorney — Garrett Moss.

Has he contacted you directly?"

My father looked up.

"How do you know that name?"

"He's done this before.

With another woman.

Eleven years ago.

Different house.

Same method." I pushed the printed court filing across the table.

"Sandra finds men in vulnerable positions.

She offers money.

She secures collateral.

She waits."

My father picked up the filing.

His hands weren't steady.

"She waited for Mom to die," I said.

"She waited for you to need her.

And then she moved in.

Literally."

He set the paper down.

He pressed two fingers against his mouth.

"What are you going to do?" he asked.

"I'm going to call a property attorney today.

And then I'm going to pay a visit to Carol Venn." I picked up my coffee.

"Because if this is a pattern, Carol Venn has evidence I don't have yet.

And evidence is the only thing that beats Garrett Moss in a room."

My father looked at me across the table — really looked at me — and for a second I saw something shift behind his eyes.

Not pride exactly.

Something older than that.

Something that looked like recognition.

"You're so much like her," he said quietly.

"Your mother.

The way she never —" His voice broke.

He stopped.

I looked at my coffee cup.

"Bring me anything else you find," I said.

"Emails.

Texts.

Anything Sandra sent you about the loan.

Anything at all."

He nodded and stood.

At the door, he paused.

"She's already told Diane that the house is half hers.

Diane's been texting her friends.

Bragging."

I looked at him.

"Good," I said.

"Let her."

He left.

I picked up my phone and dialed the number I'd found at midnight.

It rang twice.

"Carol Venn speaking," said a voice — steady, careful, the voice of someone who had learned to be both.

"My name is Nora," I said.

"You don't know me.

But I think we have the same problem.

And I think it has the same name."

A long pause.

"How did you find me?" Carol asked.

"Court records," I said.

"Eleven years old.

Garrett Moss on opposing counsel."

Another pause.

Longer.

May you like

"You'd better come in person," Carol said.

"This isn't a phone conversation."

Related Stories

Other posts