Spotlight

Chapter 6: Garrett Moss Sends a Letter

Helen Marsh had been a property attorney for twenty-three years.

Her office smelled like old paper and printer ink and, faintly, the coffee she kept on a small machine behind her desk that she never offered to share.

I liked her immediately.

I laid everything on her desk.

The loan agreement.

The court filing from eleven years ago.

The photographs of Carol's letters.

The voice recorder.

Helen listened.

She read.

She did not interrupt.

When I finished, she picked up the voice recorder and held it for a moment without pressing play.

"You understand this recording was previously ruled inadmissible in a civil proceeding," she said.

"I do."

"And you understand that admissibility in a new proceeding depends on jurisdiction, context, and the nature of the new claim."

"That's why I'm sitting here instead of playing it myself."

Helen set the recorder down.

The corner of her mouth moved, just slightly.

"Sandra Holloway's attorney filed a notice of interest this morning.

Garrett Moss.

They're asserting that her collateral claim survived your auction purchase and that she retains a partial ownership interest in the property."

"My father told me."

"They'll push for mediation first.

They always do with Moss.

It keeps things quiet and it keeps things fast.

He'll want to reach a settlement before you have time to build a proper case." Helen picked up the eleven-year-old court filing and read a section I had already read three times.

"The 'again' on this recording.

If we can establish that this is a pattern of conduct — a deliberate scheme rather than a single contractual dispute — we move from property law into something with considerably more teeth."

"Fraud," I said.

"Potentially.

Possibly elder financial exploitation, given the timeline relative to your mother's illness.

Possibly conspiracy, if Moss's involvement predates your father's case and connects to the Venn case." Helen set the filing down.

"I need to have the recorder analyzed.

I need Carol Venn's formal statement.

And I need everything your father has — every text, every email, every voicemail.

Everything."

"He said he'd cooperate."

"People say that.

Let's see if he means it." Helen looked at me directly.

"Nora.

This is going to take time.

Moss will try to rush you.

Sandra will try to frighten you.

Diane will almost certainly say something publicly that she'll regret.

You need to be prepared to hold your position while it looks like you're losing."

"I've had practice," I said.

Helen picked up her pen.

"Good.

Then let's start."

---

The letter arrived four days later.

It was from Garrett Moss's office.

Three pages, dense with legal language, asserting Sandra Holloway's ownership interest, demanding a response within ten business days, and suggesting — in the careful way that suggestions become threats — that failure to negotiate in good faith would result in a formal legal challenge to my auction purchase.

I read it once.

I photographed it.

I sent it to Helen.

Then I called my father.

"Moss sent a letter," I said.

"I know.

Sandra showed me." A pause.

"She seemed pleased."

"I need your emails.

Today.

Not tomorrow.

Today."

Another pause.

Longer.

"Nora," he said quietly, "if I send those — if this goes where it seems like it's going — Sandra will know I cooperated with you.

She'll —"

"She'll what, Dad?"

Silence.

"She already took Mom's house," I said.

"She already took Carol Venn's house.

She has an attorney who has done this before and she is already pleased that the letter landed." I kept my voice even.

"What exactly are you still afraid of losing?"

He didn't answer right away.

When he did, his voice was different.

Quieter.

Like something had settled.

"I'll send them tonight," he said.

"Thank you."

I hung up.

That night, forty-seven emails arrived in a folder my father had labeled simply: *Sandra.*

I opened the first one.

Then the second.

By the fifth, I had to put my phone face-down on the table and breathe.

She had known about my mother's diagnosis before my father had told anyone outside the family.

The email was dated two weeks before my mother was admitted to hospital for the first time.

My father hadn't told Sandra.

Sandra had already known.

I picked my phone back up and called Helen.

"Helen," I said, "I need to tell you something."

"Tell me."

"She knew about my mother's illness before my father knew she knew.

Which means someone told her.

Someone with access to medical information they shouldn't have shared."

A pause.

Then: "Forward me everything.

Tonight."

"Already sending."

I pressed send.

Then I sat in the dark of my kitchen, looking at nothing, thinking about my mother in that bed — exhausted and trusting — while someone had already been circling.

May you like

My hands were shaking.

Not from fear.

Related Stories

Other posts