Chapter 4: The Brother at the Door

Emily grabbed Michael’s arm before he could move.
“If you open that door, he’ll see Lily.”
Nathan knocked again.
“I know you’re in there, Michael.”
Claire carried Lily into the bedroom.
“Don’t tell him anything.”
Michael waited until the door closed, then looked through the peephole.
“How did he know?” I whispered.
“I came straight from the airport,” Michael said.
“Nathan called me before I left.
He said Emily was hiding something from me.”
Emily’s eyes narrowed.
“He sent you here.”
“He said you were having an affair.”
“And you believed him?”
“I came home to ask you.”
Nathan struck the door with his palm.
“Open it, or I’m calling the police.”
Michael unlocked the door but kept the chain fastened.
“What do you want, Nathan?”
Through the narrow opening, I saw Michael’s exact face staring back at us.
Nathan’s smile was colder.
“Move the chain.”
“No.”
“My daughter is inside.”
“You told the family she wasn’t yours.”
“That’s between Claire and me.”
“No,” Emily said, stepping beside Michael.
“It became our business when Claire came here terrified.”
Nathan’s smile disappeared.
“Where is she?”
“Somewhere you can’t control her,” I said.
His eyes moved to me.
“And who are you supposed to be?”
“The woman whose house your daughter’s clothes have been going to.”
Nathan pushed against the door, but the chain held.
“You helped Claire hide Lily from me.”
“I helped my sister do laundry.
Now I understand why she lied.”
Nathan raised a folder into view.
“I have a temporary custody order.
If Claire keeps Lily from me, she will be the one answering questions.”
Michael reached through the gap.
“Let me see it.”
Nathan pulled it back.
“Remove the chain first.”
A small whimper came from the bedroom.
Nathan tilted his head.
“There she is.”
He shoved the door again.
The screws holding the chain plate shifted.
“Stop!” Emily cried.
The apartment door across the hall opened.
An older woman in a blue cardigan stepped out with her phone raised.
“I’m recording you,” she said.
Nathan turned.
“Go back inside, Mrs.
Alvarez.”
“No.
I’ve listened to you pound on this door twice this week.”
Emily stared at her.
“Twice?”
Mrs.
Alvarez kept the camera on Nathan.
“Tuesday night and yesterday morning.
I saved both recordings.”
Nathan lowered his voice.
“You don’t understand what’s happening.”
“I understand a grown man trying to force his way into a home where a child is crying.”
Nathan stepped toward her.
Michael pushed the door closed and locked it.
“Claire needs to leave now,” Mrs.
Alvarez called through the wood.
“My back stairway opens behind the building.”
Emily ran to the bedroom.
Claire emerged carrying Lily, and Mrs.
Alvarez unlocked her apartment from the outside.
“Go through my kitchen,” she said.
“The rear door is open.”
Claire caught her hand.
“Why are you helping us?”
Mrs.
Alvarez looked at Lily.
“Because years ago, nobody opened a door for me.”
Claire and Lily disappeared into her apartment.
I followed, but Emily stayed with Michael.
From the hallway, Nathan shouted, “You’re making the biggest mistake of your life!”
Mrs.
Alvarez pushed a ring of keys into my hand.
“My car is behind the bakery.
Take them to your house.”
“What about you?”
“I’m seventy-two.
I can survive an angry man in an expensive coat.”
We reached the back stairway.
Claire carried Lily down while I held the railing and searched for the car.
Then police sirens sounded at the front of the building.
Claire stopped halfway down.
May you like
“He has the order,” she whispered.
“If they find us running, Nathan wins.”