Chapter 3: The Man With the Same Face

A little girl stepped into the hallway, clutching a stuffed rabbit against her chest.
The moment she saw Emily’s husband, she stumbled backward.
“No!
You said he wouldn’t find us!”
Emily rushed to her.
“Lily, this is Michael.
He isn’t the man who frightened you.”
“But he has Daddy’s face.”
Michael gripped the drawing so tightly that the paper bent.
“Emily, why does she think I’m her father?”
A woman appeared behind Lily.
One side of her face was marked with a fading bruise, and her hand rested protectively on the child’s shoulder.
Michael whispered, “Claire?”
“Hello, Michael.”
I looked from Michael to the man in Lily’s drawing.
“Someone needs to explain this now.”
Michael lowered the paper.
“I have an identical twin brother.
His name is Nathan.”
“And Nathan is Lily’s father,” Claire said.
Michael took a step toward her.
Lily hid behind Emily.
“Stay back,” Claire warned.
“I’m not Nathan.”
“You defended him every time I tried to tell your family what he was doing.”
Michael’s mouth opened, but no words came.
Emily faced him.
“That’s why I couldn’t tell you they were here.”
“You thought I would hand them over to him?”
“I thought you’d call Nathan and ask for his side.”
Michael flinched.
Claire pointed toward the laundry room.
“Those were our clothes.
Emily took most of them to her sister’s house whenever you were home.
When you traveled, she washed Lily’s things here.”
I stared at Emily.
“You could have trusted me.”
“I wanted to.
But the fewer people who knew, the safer they were.”
Michael placed the drawing on the table.
“Why are you hiding from Nathan?”
Claire pulled Lily closer.
“Because I found documents in his office.
He opened accounts using my name and Lily’s trust fund.”
“What trust fund?” I asked.
“Your father’s family trust,” Claire told Michael.
“The first grandchild received two million dollars for education and medical care.”
Michael’s face changed.
“Nathan told us Lily wasn’t his.”
“He said that because he didn’t want anyone examining the account.
He has already taken more than half of it.”
“That’s impossible.
Every withdrawal requires two signatures.”
Claire’s voice hardened.
“One was mine.
The other was yours.”
Michael stared at her.
“I never signed anything.”
“No,” Claire said.
“Nathan signed your name.”
Emily picked up her phone.
“Claire photographed the documents.
We were going to meet a lawyer tomorrow.”
“Where are the photographs?” Michael asked.
“On a phone Nathan doesn’t know about.”
Claire reached into her coat, then suddenly stopped.
“The phone was in Lily’s backpack.”
Lily looked toward the bedroom.
“It’s under the bed.”
Emily hurried down the hallway.
Before she reached the door, her own phone buzzed on the table.
She glanced at the screen and went still.
“What is it?” I asked.
Emily turned the phone toward us.
The message contained only six words.
I KNOW CLAIRE AND LILY ARE THERE.
Michael looked toward the front door.
A heavy knock shook it in its frame.
Then a man’s voice called from the hallway.
May you like
“Michael, open the door.
We need to talk.”