Chapter 5: What He Did to Robert

"Sit down, Daniel."
He didn't sit down this time.
He walked to the window and stood with his back to me, looking out at the driveway.
His car was still running.
He had left the engine on when he came back inside, like some part of him had known this would be quick.
"Your brother has been filling your head with things he doesn't understand," he said.
I kept my voice level.
"You told me Robert was de@d."
He turned from the window.
"I told you he was gone.
That he had left the country and cut off contact.
I never said—"
"You showed me a photograph," I said.
"Of a grave."
The room went quiet.
"You showed me a photograph of a grave with his name on it.
You said his old friends had sent it to you.
That he had gone to Southeast Asia and d*ed in some accident and that his friends over there had buried him quietly because there was no one else." My voice stayed flat.
"You told me this sitting at this table.
In this kitchen.
You held my hand while I cried."
Daniel said nothing.
"That was four years ago," I said.
"Robert has been alive for every single one of those four years."
"He is not a safe person," Daniel said.
"I was protecting you."
"From your brother."
"From a man who has made very poor choices.
Who has been involved in situations that could have put you at risk."
"What situations?" I said.
"Name one."
He turned back to the window.
"It's not something I'm prepared to discuss right now."
"Then sit down and discuss what you are prepared to discuss.
The apartment.
The money.
Her."
He turned around slowly.
"Claire is not your concern."
"Daniel."
"She is not your concern."
"She is living in an apartment with your name on the lease, paid for with money that belongs to both of us, and you have been lying to me about where you go twice a month for over a year." I stood up from the table.
"She is absolutely my concern."
He looked at me for a long moment.
There was something shifting behind his eyes.
I had seen it before — that slight recalibration when a conversation was not going the way he had planned.
When the other person was not behaving the way he expected.
"I think," he said carefully, "that you and I should take the evening to calm down before we talk about any of this."
"I am calm," I said.
"You're upset.
Understandably.
But you've been given incomplete information by someone who has reasons to want to damage our marriage, and I think before we—"
"Robert didn't tell me about the money," I said.
He stopped.
"I found that myself."
That wasn't true.
But he didn't know what I had and what I hadn't seen.
And I watched that uncertainty cross his face for just a moment before he locked it away again.
"I'd like you to call your brother," Daniel said.
"And ask him to come here.
Tonight.
I think the three of us need to have a conversation."
My phone was on the counter behind me.
I didn't reach for it.
Because Daniel asking Robert to come here was not an invitation to talk.
Daniel had spent four years keeping Robert away from me using a photograph of a grave.
The last thing I was going to do was hand him a second chance.
"No," I said.
Something in Daniel's face changed.
Not anger.
May you like
Something colder than that.
"Then I think," he said quietly, "that you should consider very carefully what you do next."