Chapter 4: The First Lie

Neither of us spoke for a long moment.
He was still holding his keys.
His travel bag was over one shoulder.
He had only been gone eleven minutes.
Whatever he had forgotten, he hadn't gone to get it yet.
He had come through the front door and stopped cold at the sight of that single photograph lying on the kitchen table.
"Where did you get that?" he said.
"Sit down, Daniel."
His name came out steadier than I expected.
I hadn't planned for that.
I hadn't planned for any of this.
He didn't sit down.
"I asked you a question," he said.
"And I asked you to sit down."
He set his bag on the floor near the door.
He didn't come any closer.
He stood at the edge of the hallway with his keys still in his hand, looking at the photograph like he was trying to calculate exactly how much I knew.
"That's not what it looks like," he said.
"Sit down, Daniel."
He crossed the room slowly and sat in the chair across from me.
His eyes moved from the photograph to my face and back again.
"Her name is Claire," he said.
"She's a colleague.
We were reviewing a property together.
That's all that is."
"You're renting her an apartment," I said.
He blinked.
"The lease has your name on it," I said.
"Fourteen months.
Same building as that photograph."
"That's—" He stopped.
"That's what?"
He put his keys on the table.
Not near the photograph.
On the far edge, as far from it as he could place them.
"She needed somewhere to stay," he said.
"She was in a difficult situation.
I was trying to help."
"With our retirement savings."
The silence that followed was the loudest thing I had ever heard inside this house.
"You don't understand the full picture," Daniel said.
"Then explain it to me."
He leaned forward slightly.
His voice dropped to something careful and measured, the voice he used when he was managing a situation rather than talking to a person.
"There are things about my work that I haven't been able to tell you," he said.
"Things I've been protecting you from.
This is more complicated than it looks."
"More complicated than your name on a lease," I said.
"For a woman I've never heard of."
"Yes."
"More complicated than money leaving our account every month for two years."
He went very still.
"How much do you know?" he said.
It was the wrong question.
He knew it the moment it left his mouth.
I watched him realize it.
His jaw tightened slightly and he looked down at the table.
"I know enough," I said.
"Who told you?" he asked.
"Who have you been talking to?"
And there it was.
Not denial.
Not explanation.
Not even a convincing attempt at either.
Just that question, asked in a voice that had suddenly gone from careful to something harder underneath.
Who have you been talking to.
Not what have you found.
Not let me explain.
Who.
Because Daniel had spent seven years making sure I had no one.
He just didn't know that had changed four years ago when he told me my brother was dangerous and I should cut him off — and I said yes, and smiled, and went on pretending.
"It doesn't matter who I've been talking to," I said.
Daniel stood up from the table.
May you like
"I think it does," he said.
"I think it matters quite a lot."