Chapter 4: What Dorothy Remembered

It took me three days to call Dorothy Marsh.
Not because I couldn't find the number.
I found it on the second day, written on the back of a Christmas card from four years ago that I had tucked inside a shoebox in the hallway closet.
I just kept picking up the phone and putting it down.
My husband didn't push me.
He knew the shape of the thing I was afraid of.
When you are sixty-one years old and your mother has been gone for nine years, you believe you have made peace with not knowing certain things.
You believe the questions that were never answered have simply closed.
Softly.
Without ceremony.
The locket told me they had not.
I called on a Wednesday morning while my husband was out.
Dorothy answered on the third ring.
Her voice was older than I remembered.
Slower.
But warm in the same way it had always been.
"My goodness," she said.
"Carol.
It's been years."
"I know.
I'm sorry for that."
"Don't be sorry.
We're old women, the two of us.
Time gets away."
I almost lost my nerve then.
Almost said I was simply calling to check in.
"Dorothy," I said instead, "I need to ask you something about my mother.
Something I never thought to ask when she was alive."
A short pause.
"All right," she said.
"Did my mother ever mention anyone with the initials E.V.?
Before she was married.
Before she was Ruth Dawson."
The pause this time was longer.
My hand tightened on the phone.
"Dorothy?"
"Where did you hear that?" she said.
Her voice had shifted.
Not unfriendly.
But careful.
The way a person sounds when they are deciding how much to say.
"I found something," I said.
"In the house.
A locket that belonged to her.
It had a photo inside I didn't recognize.
And initials scratched on the back." I stopped.
"E.V."
Dorothy was quiet for so long I thought the call had dropped.
"Dorothy."
"I told her," she said finally.
Very quietly.
"I told her someday someone would find out.
She said she'd rather it happen after she was gone than while she was here to see the look on people's faces."
My legs went strange.
I sat down at the kitchen table without deciding to.
"What are you telling me?" I said.
"Your mother had a sister," Dorothy said.
"A younger sister.
Evelyn Voss.
That was her name before your grandmother remarried and took the name Dawson.
Evelyn Voss."
E.V.
"My mother told me she was an only child," I said.
The words came out flat.
Not accusing.
Just flat.
"I know she did."
"She told me that my entire life."
"I know, Carol."
"Why?" I said.
"Why would she do that?
What happened to Evelyn?"
Dorothy made a sound that wasn't quite a sigh and wasn't quite a word.
"Your grandmother gave Evelyn up," she said.
"Before she remarried.
Before your mother was old enough to understand why.
She gave the baby to another family and told your mother the child hadn't survived." A pause.
"Your mother found out the truth when she was seventeen.
She tracked Evelyn down.
They met twice."
"Twice," I repeated.
"And then Evelyn told her not to come back."
The kitchen was very still.
"She didn't want to know your mother?" I said.
"She didn't want to know any of it," Dorothy said.
"She'd been raised in a different family.
A good family, from what I understand.
She said meeting your mother made her feel like something in her life that had been solid was suddenly not solid anymore.
She asked your mother to leave her in peace."
I looked at the locket on the table in front of me.
The woman with the dark hair and the serious expression that was not quite unhappy.
"The photo," I said.
"In the locket.
That's Evelyn."
"I expect so," Dorothy said.
"Your mother never showed it to me.
But she kept something of hers, that much I knew.
She said she just wanted one thing that proved the girl had been real."
My eyes were burning.
"Did Evelyn have children?" I said.
Another pause.
"Dorothy.
Did Evelyn have children?"
"I don't know," she said.
"Your mother stopped talking about her after a while.
I think it hurt too much to keep revisiting it." She paused again.
"Why are you asking, Carol?
What is it you're really trying to find out?"
I looked at the locket.
I thought about an eight-year-old girl arriving at my door with a duffel bag and a plastic grocery bag full of clothes.
I thought about the way she asked for permission before opening the refrigerator.
A thought moved through me that I did not say out loud.
Not yet.
"I'm not sure," I told Dorothy.
"But thank you.
Thank you for telling me."
After I hung up, I sat at that table for a long time.
When my husband came home, he found me there, still holding the phone.
"Well?" he said.
I looked up at him.
"My mother had a sister she never told me about," I said.
"Her name was Evelyn Voss."
He came and sat across from me.
"And the locket?"
"Was hers."
He waited.
"Dorothy doesn't know if Evelyn had children," I said.
I set the phone down.
Pressed both hands flat on the table.
"But I keep thinking about something.
About the name of the family Evelyn was given to.
About whether anyone ever looked into that."
He was watching me very carefully now.
"You're thinking about Ivy," he said.
I didn't answer.
He leaned forward.
"Carol."
"I know," I said.
"I know it's probably nothing.
I know it's probably a coincidence and I'm seeing a shape that isn't there." I looked at him.
"But she showed up at our door.
After eighteen years.
And the locket she returned had my mother's sister's photograph inside it."
He sat back.
Outside, the afternoon light shifted across the garden.
"So what do we do?" he said quietly.
May you like
I looked at the locket on the table.
"I think," I said, "we need to ask Ivy something."