Chapter 3: Two Letters That Unmade Everything

The initials were E.V.
I said them out loud without meaning to.
"E.V."
My husband looked at me.
"What?"
"The initials." I held the locket out so he could see the back.
"E.V.
That was not my mother's name.
That was not anyone in her family."
He took the locket carefully.
Turned it.
Squinted at the scratched letters.
Ivy was very still across the table.
"You know what it means," she said.
It was not a question.
"No," I said.
"I don't.
That's what's frightening me."
My mother's name had been Ruth.
Her maiden name started with a D.
Her mother before her, my grandmother, was Agnes.
There was no E.
There was no V.
Not anywhere in the family I had been told about.
My husband set the locket down between us.
"Could it have been a gift?" he said.
"To your mother.
From someone else."
"Then why keep a stranger's photo inside it?"
He didn't have an answer.
Ivy leaned forward slightly.
"Can I ask something?"
We both looked at her.
"Did your mother ever talk about a sister?"
The question landed strangely.
I felt it before I understood why.
"She was an only child," I said.
"She always said that.
She used to say it like it was something she was proud of.
'I learned early to be my own company.'"
Ivy nodded slowly.
She was looking at the locket, not at me.
"I used to make up a story about the woman in the photo," she said.
"When I was little.
I told myself she was someone who loved the baby so much she had to carry her everywhere, even inside a piece of jewelry." She paused.
"I didn't think about whether the story was true.
I just needed it to be."
My throat tightened.
My husband reached across and put his hand over mine.
"We should call your mother's sister," he said.
"She didn't have a sister."
"Her friends, then.
Someone who knew her before you were born."
I thought about that.
My mother had been private in the way that some people are private — not secretive exactly, but contained.
She didn't speak much about her childhood.
When I asked, she would say something brief and then redirect the conversation.
I had always assumed it was just her nature.
Now I was not sure.
"There's one person," I said slowly.
He waited.
"Dorothy Marsh.
She and my mother grew up on the same street.
They stayed in touch until my mother's last few years.
She used to send Christmas cards." I stopped.
"I haven't spoken to her since the funeral."
"Do you have her number?"
"I have her daughter's number.
I think."
Ivy was watching me carefully.
"You don't have to do this today," she said.
"I didn't come here to upset you.
I came to return what I took and to say I was sorry.
Whatever this is—" she gestured at the locket—"it was here before I arrived.
I just carried it somewhere safe."
Something about the way she said that made me look at her more carefully.
"You really did think of it that way, didn't you?" I said.
"Carrying it somewhere safe."
She looked down at her hands.
"I told you.
I needed something from this house to belong to me." A beat.
"I didn't expect it to come with a mystery attached."
My husband almost smiled at that.
I picked up the locket again.
Opened it again.
Looked at the woman I didn't know.
The baby whose face was too small and too faded to read clearly.
The woman in the photo had dark hair.
Pinned back.
A serious expression that wasn't quite unhappy.
My mother had dark hair too.
I had always assumed I inherited it from her.
"E.V.," I said again, quietly.
Ivy looked up.
"My mother's name before she married was Eleanor.
Eleanor Ruth Dawson." I set the locket down on the table.
"But she went by Ruth her entire life.
She said Eleanor was too formal.
She said she never liked it." I looked at the initials on the back of the locket one more time.
"Her maiden name started with a D.
Not a V."
"But her first name," my husband said carefully.
"Eleanor.
The E fits."
The room went very quiet.
"The V doesn't," I said.
He looked at me.
"Unless," I said, and then I stopped, because the thought that had just arrived was one I did not know how to finish.
Ivy's eyes moved between us.
"Unless what?" she asked.
I stood up.
Walked to the window.
Stood there looking out at the front garden without seeing any of it.
"Unless my mother's name wasn't Dawson before she married," I said.
"Unless Dawson was already a second name.
A name she took from someone else."
My husband was quiet for a long moment.
Then he said, very carefully: "Are you saying you think she might have changed her name?"
I turned back from the window.
"I'm saying I don't know who Eleanor V.
was.
And I'm saying my mother carried that woman's photograph inside a locket for her entire life and never once told me it existed."
Ivy was looking at the locket on the table.
She reached out and touched the edge of it.
Didn't pick it up.
Just touched it.
May you like
"I kept it safe for eighteen years," she said softly.
"I didn't know I was keeping a secret."