Chapter 7: What David Said When They Came

My sister Carol drove down from Springfield that night and I slept in her guest room for the first time since we were teenagers.
I didn't sleep.
But I lay in the dark and listened to her house — the heat clicking on, a dog somewhere on the street, her kids' nightlight making a thin stripe of yellow under the door — and those small ordinary sounds kept me from going somewhere inside myself that I might not have come back from easily.
Detective Colburn called at six-fifteen in the morning.
"We executed the search warrant last night," he said.
"Mr.
Marsh was present during the search.
He invoked his right to counsel immediately."
"Did he say anything before he lawyered up?"
A short pause.
"He said the iPad was fabricated.
That Owen had been a troubled kid who had developed an obsession with his parents' marriage, and that the photos on the device couldn't be verified as authentic."
My hand tightened on the phone.
"He said that about Owen."
"Yes."
I sat on the edge of the guest bed.
"What about the texts?
The ones Owen photographed?"
"His attorney is going to argue they're screenshots of conversations that never happened.
That Owen staged them." Colburn's voice was level, careful.
"I want you to be prepared for that, Mrs.
Marsh.
His attorney is good.
He's going to try to dismantle every piece of evidence by dismantling Owen's credibility."
"Owen was thirteen," I said.
"He hid a backup iPad in his school locker and took covert photographs of a credit card statement because he was afraid for his life.
That doesn't sound like a troubled kid to me."
"It doesn't to me either," Colburn said.
"And it won't to a jury.
But I need you to know what the defense is going to look like."
"What else did you find in the house?"
Another pause.
Longer this time.
"A burner phone," he said.
"In the garage.
Behind a shelf unit.
It had been wiped, but our tech team is working on recovering the data." He paused again.
"And we found a life insurance policy on Owen.
Taken out eleven months ago.
Two hundred and fifty thousand dollars.
David Marsh is the sole beneficiary."
The guest room tilted.
I grabbed the nightstand.
"He took out a life insurance policy on our son," I said.
"Eleven months ago," Colburn confirmed.
"Owen would have been twelve."
I thought about the year before the trip.
David suggesting family activities.
The fishing trip in the first place — it had been David's idea, that first year he invited Owen along.
I had thought it was a turning point.
I had been grateful.
I had told my sister, *I think they're finally building something.*
"Diane." It was the first time Colburn had used my first name.
"I want you to know that the DA's office has been briefed.
This is being treated as a homicide investigation.
That determination was made last night."
I sat very still.
"He's going to try to claim it was an accident," I said.
"Yes."
"Paula Reeves saw what she saw."
"Yes," Colburn said again.
"And Owen saw what he saw.
And he made sure we'd know it." He cleared his throat quietly.
"There's one more thing.
We identified Carla.
Her full name is Carla Prentiss.
She lives in Branson.
We made contact with her this morning."
"And?"
"She says she didn't know anything about what David was planning.
She's already agreed to cooperate fully with the investigation."
I exhaled slowly.
"Does she have anything that ties him to it?"
"She has three years of communications," Colburn said.
"And she says there's a conversation she recorded.
Last year.
In which David spoke about Owen knowing too much about their arrangement, and what he said he would do if the problem didn't resolve itself."
Outside the guest room door, I could hear Carol starting coffee in the kitchen.
"He recorded himself," I said quietly.
"She recorded him," Colburn said.
"She kept it because she was afraid of him herself."
I pressed my hand over my eyes.
My boy had not been alone in seeing the truth.
He had just been the only one young enough, and brave enough, and foolish enough with love to believe that knowing the truth meant the worst wouldn't happen.
May you like
"What happens now?" I said.
"Now," Colburn said, "we build the case."