Chapter 4: What Paula Saw From the Dock

Paula Reeves opened her front door before I even knocked.
She must have been watching from the window.
She was younger than I expected — early forties, dark circles under her eyes, wearing a sweatshirt with a school logo on it.
She stepped back to let me in without saying anything, and I followed her into a kitchen that smelled like burnt coffee.
She didn't offer me any.
She just sat down at the table and folded her hands on top of it, and I sat across from her, and for a moment neither of us spoke.
"I should have called you sooner," she finally said.
"I know that."
"Tell me what you saw."
She looked at her hands.
"My husband and I arrived at the lake the evening before.
We weren't there for the fishing trip — we didn't know David's group was going to be there.
We just go up most weekends when the weather is decent." She paused.
"The next morning I got up early.
Around six.
I took my coffee down to our dock to watch the water before the kids woke up."
"And?"
"Your cabin dock is visible from ours.
It's maybe two hundred yards across the water." She looked up at me.
"The storm hadn't started yet.
The water was completely still."
My jaw tightened.
"David said the storm was already hitting when Owen fell."
"The storm didn't start until after nine," Paula said.
"I was inside making breakfast by then.
But at six in the morning the lake was flat.
No wind.
No rain."
I stared at her.
"I saw them on the dock," she said quietly.
"David and Owen.
I didn't think anything of it at first — a dad and his son, early morning, standing near the water." She stopped.
Swallowed.
"They were arguing.
I could tell from the body language even from that distance.
Owen kept stepping back and David kept stepping forward.
And then—"
She pressed her lips together.
"Then what?" My voice came out barely above a sound.
"Owen went into the water," she said.
"But Diane — he didn't slip.
He was standing at the edge, and David put both hands on his shoulders, and Owen went into the water."
The kitchen went completely silent.
"I told myself I hadn't seen it right," she said, her voice cracking.
"That the light was strange.
That I was too far away.
That it was an accident and David must have been trying to grab him.
I told myself every version of that story I could think of for weeks." She wiped her eye with the back of her wrist.
"But I keep seeing it.
Every time I close my eyes at night.
The way Owen's arms came up.
The way David just — stood there after."
"He stood there," I repeated.
"For almost a minute," Paula said.
"Before he started calling out."
I looked at the table between us.
There was a crayon drawing half-tucked under a fruit bowl.
A child's drawing of a house and a sun and a family with stick arms.
"I need you to tell the police," I said.
"I know."
"I need you to do it today."
She nodded, but her hands were shaking.
"What if he finds out I talked?
He knows where I work, Diane.
He knows this is my neighborhood.
He came to the school and he shook my hand in the hallway and looked right at me and I—"
"I know," I said.
"I know you're scared."
I reached across the table and covered her hands with mine.
"So was Owen," I said.
"He was thirteen years old and he was scared, and he still found a way to tell the truth.
He just needed someone to carry it the rest of the way."
Paula looked at me for a long moment.
Then she pulled her phone out of her sweatshirt pocket and set it on the table between us.
"Tell me who to call," she said.
My own phone buzzed in my jacket.
I pulled it out.
A text from David.
*Hey.
Where are you?
Your car's not in the driveway.
Everything okay?*
I turned the phone face-down on the table.
May you like
"Call 911," I said.
"Tell them you have information about Owen Marsh."