Spotlight

Chapter 5: The Man Who Came Home for Dinner

I drove back to the house.

I don't fully remember making the decision to do it.

My hands just turned the wheel in that direction, and before I'd formed any real plan my car was in the driveway and the front door was unlocked and David was standing in the kitchen making pasta.

He looked up when I came in.

He smiled.

That was the thing that undid something in me — the ease of that smile.

The complete, comfortable normalcy of it.

"There you are," he said.

"I was starting to get worried.

Where'd you go?"

"For a drive."

"You should've texted me." He turned back to the stove and stirred the pot.

"You doing okay?

You look pale."

I set my bag down on the counter.

Owen's letter was inside it.

The iPad was not — I had left it locked in my car.

After Paula had made her call, I had gone to the school with Mrs.

Dilmore and retrieved the iPad from Owen's locker myself.

I hadn't turned it on yet.

I wasn't ready.

But I had it.

"I went to see Mrs.

Dilmore," I said.

David's spoon slowed in the pot.

Just slightly.

Then resumed.

"Owen's teacher?

What for?"

"She found something in her classroom.

When she was cleaning out her desk."

He turned around.

His expression was careful.

Not frightened — careful.

Measured.

The face of a man deciding which version of himself to present.

"Found what?"

"A note," I said.

"From Owen."

The spoon stopped moving.

He set it on the edge of the pot.

"A note," he repeated.

"He left it for me.

Taped under her desk drawer.

He wanted to make sure I'd get it if anything ever happened to him."

David was quiet for three full seconds.

I counted them.

"What did it say?" he asked.

"It said he loved me."

Another silence.

David picked the spoon back up.

"That's sweet.

He was a thoughtful kid." He turned back to the stove.

"Dinner's almost ready.

You should eat something, Diane.

You haven't been eating enough."

I looked at the back of his head.

The familiar set of his shoulders.

The same man who had held me at Owen's memorial while I could barely stand.

"He also wrote about Carla," I said.

The pot lid rattled.

David's hand shot out and steadied it.

He did not turn around.

"I don't know who that is," he said.

The words came out too flat, too fast, like he'd already rehearsed the shape of them.

"He saw you together at the gas station on Route 9.

Last spring.

He said you were laughing."

A long pause.

"Owen had an active imagination sometimes, Diane.

You know that.

He was a kid.

He saw two people he didn't recognize—"

"He recognized you, David."

He turned around now.

His jaw was set.

Something behind his eyes had shifted — the careful version of himself was gone, and what replaced it was harder.

"I think you're not well," he said, quietly.

"I think the grief is making you see things that aren't—"

"Paula Reeves called the police this afternoon," I said.

The color left his face.

Not gradually.

All at once, like a lamp switched off.

"She was at the lake that morning," I said.

"Early.

Before the storm.

She was on her cabin dock and she had a clear view of ours."

David said nothing.

His hand found the counter behind him.

"She watched you and Owen arguing on the dock," I said.

"She saw what happened."

The pasta boiled over behind him.

Neither of us moved.

"You need to stop talking," he said.

His voice had dropped to something I had never heard from him before.

Something with no warmth in it at all.

"You are grieving and you are not thinking clearly and you need to stop—"

"I already talked to the police myself," I said.

"An hour ago.

I gave them Owen's letter and I told them about the iPad."

His chin came up.

"The iPad," he said carefully.

"Owen's iPad was in his bag.

It went into the lake."

"His backup iPad," I said.

"The one he kept at school."

David's hand tightened against the counter edge.

The knuckles went pale.

"You have no idea what you're doing," he said.

My phone buzzed on the counter.

I looked at the screen.

Detective Ray Colburn.

Ozark County Sheriff's Department.

May you like

I picked it up.

"I'll be right back," I said, and walked out of the kitchen to answer it.

Related Stories

Other posts