Chapter 5: What Daniel Heard

"I was in the hallway," Daniel said.
"Looking for the bathroom.
The kitchen door wasn't fully closed."
He didn't look at Camille while he spoke.
He looked at Adrian.
"I heard Camille tell Naomi that if she ever said anything to you — about the money, about being kept upstairs, about any of it — she would make sure you believed Naomi was the problem.
That she'd been causing trouble since the beginning.
That she resented the marriage."
No one in the room moved.
"She told her," Daniel continued, "that you would always choose the marriage.
Those were the words she used.
That you would always choose the marriage, and Naomi would end up with nothing."
Adrian's hand was at his side.
His fingers pressed flat against his thigh.
Naomi stared at the floor between her feet.
"Is that true?" Adrian asked her.
"Did she say that to you?"
Naomi nodded once.
"More than once," she said.
"Different versions.
But the same message."
Adrian turned.
Camille was standing with her arms crossed now, her weight shifted back slightly — the posture of someone who had decided the ground was no longer safe and was looking for higher footing.
"I was managing a difficult situation," she said.
"Naomi came into this marriage with resentment already built in.
Anyone who knew the circumstances would understand what I was dealing with."
"What circumstances?" Adrian asked.
"Your divorce.
Your ex-wife.
The fact that Naomi spent years being told—"
"Don't talk about her mother," Adrian said.
"I'm giving you context—"
"You're building a story." His voice didn't rise.
It dropped.
Which was worse.
"You're doing right now what Daniel said you told her you would do.
You're making her the problem."
Camille's jaw tightened.
"Think about what you're doing, Adrian.
You're taking the word of a twenty-two-year-old girl and a friend who filmed a private moment in our home without permission—"
"He filmed it because something was wrong," Adrian said.
"He filmed it because—"
"Because something was wrong," Adrian said again.
Slower.
"And everyone in this room could see it except me.
Because you made sure I couldn't."
Ruth stood up from her chair.
She didn't say anything at first.
She just stood.
But her standing changed the air in the room.
She was in her sixties, had known Adrian since before his first marriage, and when she spoke, people tended to listen.
"Camille," Ruth said.
"I was here that evening too.
The last visit."
Camille looked at her.
"I saw Naomi's plate in the kitchen sink when I went to rinse my glass.
There was food still on it.
She hadn't finished eating." Ruth paused.
"I asked you where she was and you told me she'd gone to bed early.
She doesn't sleep well." She tilted her head slightly.
"Naomi, do you have trouble sleeping?"
Naomi looked up at her.
"No," she said.
Ruth nodded slowly.
Sat back down.
The room absorbed that.
Camille set her glass on the side table with a small, careful click.
"I think," she said, "that this has gone far enough for one evening." She looked at Adrian directly.
"Whatever you think you've understood tonight, I'd ask you to wait until we're alone before you make any decisions.
For the sake of the marriage.
For the sake of what we've built."
Adrian looked at her for a long moment.
Then he walked to the sofa and sat down beside Naomi.
Not across the room from her.
Beside her.
He didn't say anything.
He just sat there, and that single movement — the choosing of where to put his body — told Camille something that no amount of talking could have.
Camille picked up her glass.
May you like
Her hand was steady.
But the glass was empty, and she didn't seem to realize it until she'd already raised it to her lips.