Spotlight

Chapter 11: The Version She Told

Camille moved fast.

By Wednesday, Adrian had heard from three people.

Ruth called first, early in the morning, to say that Camille had reached out.

"She told me Naomi has had a history of making accusations against women in her father's life," Ruth said.

"Apparently it happened with someone before me too — a woman your ex-wife dated briefly.

I wanted to tell you immediately."

Adrian thanked her.

His colleague James mentioned it at the office, awkward and clearly reluctant.

"Camille rang Sarah last night.

Sarah mentioned it to me.

She said Naomi had been struggling emotionally and that the birthday incident had been blown out of proportion by people who didn't have the full background.

She said you'd been misled." James shook his head.

"I didn't know what to do with that, so I'm telling you."

The third was a text from Daniel.

*She called me.

Tried to explain the video.

Said I misunderstood the context.

Said the kitchen was Naomi's chosen quiet space.

Her words.

I told her I knew what I saw and heard.

She thanked me for my time and hung up.*

Adrian sat in his office and read the messages in order.

Camille was doing exactly what Naomi had said she would do.

She was building the story.

Distributing it quietly.

Making sure that by the time anything official happened — by the time the solicitor's letter arrived, by the time any mutual friend had to pick a side — her version was already the one people had heard first.

He called his solicitor.

"Can we move the appointment to this week?"

"Thursday morning," his solicitor said.

"Ten o'clock."

He took it.

That evening, he sat across from Naomi at the kitchen table again.

"She's telling people," he said.

"A version.

That you make accusations.

That it's a pattern."

Naomi's expression didn't change.

"I know," she said.

"She told me she would.

If I ever pushed.

She said no one would believe me because she'd make sure they already had a reason not to."

"She said that."

"Yes."

"On the recording?"

Naomi shook her head slowly.

"Before.

In the kitchen.

The day she first explained the rules." She looked at her hands.

"I should have started recording much earlier."

"You were twenty-two and living in her house," Adrian said.

"You were surviving."

She didn't respond to that.

"Naomi." He waited until she looked at him.

"I want to ask you something and I need you to answer honestly."

She nodded.

"Is there anything — any version of any of this — where she has a point?

Where something you did made this harder?

Where something you said gave her a real reason?"

He asked it because it needed to be asked.

Because his solicitor would ask it, and Camille's solicitor would certainly raise it, and he needed to know now.

Naomi was quiet for a moment.

"I wasn't easy to love," she said.

"When I first moved in, I was angry.

About the divorce.

About being uprooted.

I was cold to her.

I didn't try." She paused.

"But I was seventeen.

And she was the adult.

And what I did at seventeen doesn't explain what she did for the three years after."

"No," he said.

"It doesn't."

He looked at the window.

Outside, the evening was quiet.

A neighbor's light.

A car moving slowly down the street.

"Thursday," he said.

"You're coming with me.

To the solicitor."

Naomi looked up.

"I want them to hear it from you directly," he said.

"The timeline.

The rules.

The money from your mother.

What she said about the marriage.

The recording."

"You want to use the recording?"

"Yes."

She looked at the phone on the table between them.

"She's going to say it was obtained illegally.

That I recorded without consent."

"Let her say it."

"She's going to say a lot of things, Dad."

The word landed quietly.

She hadn't used it once since she'd come downstairs three nights ago in her sweater.

Adrian looked at his daughter.

"Let her," he said.

May you like

"We know what happened.

And so does everyone who was in this room on Saturday night."

Related Stories

Other posts