Chapter 8: The Doctor Talks

Dr.
Ellison Krauss had retired eighteen months earlier to a house on the coast of Maine.
He was seventy-one years old.
He had built a careful reputation over a forty-year career in reproductive medicine, and he had spent the last eighteen months, according to Gerald's contact at the licensing board, thinking about a phone call he did not want to make.
Gerald drove up to see him in person.
He called me that evening from a gas station two hours south of the Maine border, on his way back.
"He talked," Gerald said.
I sat down.
"He talked for an hour and a half," Gerald said.
"I have it recorded with his full consent.
He's prepared to submit a formal declaration to the court."
"What did he say?"
Gerald was quiet for a moment.
The kind of quiet that means a person is choosing how to carry something toward you carefully.
"Margaret Whitmore contacted him privately, before your second treatment cycle.
She represented herself as a concerned family member wanting to understand the full scope of the protocol.
He says she asked very specific questions about hormonal timing — about what adjustments might reduce the likelihood of a successful implantation without being detectable in a standard review."
I didn't say anything.
"He says he told her that such adjustments were possible but that he would never recommend them outside of a clinical necessity.
He says she thanked him and left." Gerald paused.
"He says he didn't know at the time that she had access to your treating physician's schedule.
He didn't know she had spoken to anyone else on your care team."
"But someone adjusted the protocol," I said.
"Your second cycle records show a deviation from the standard dosing timeline," Gerald said.
"Small enough that it wasn't flagged in the standard review.
Significant enough that, in Krauss's professional opinion, it would have materially reduced the probability of a successful outcome."
A long silence.
"He's been carrying this for four years?" I said.
"He says he didn't know until after you had your second miscarriage," Gerald said.
"He says a colleague mentioned the deviation in passing — a chart review, something routine.
He says he looked into it and by the time he understood what he was looking at, the family had moved on to another clinic and there was nothing he could formally document without more proof."
"And now there's the ledger," I said.
"And now there's the ledger," Gerald said.
"His name.
The payment.
The date.
It matches the consultation he described.
He didn't take the money, Claire.
His name is in there, but he says he never received a payment and never agreed to any arrangement."
"Then why is his name there?"
"Margaret," Gerald said simply.
"Covering her tracks.
Putting his name next to a payment creates the appearance of an agreement.
If he ever spoke up, she could claim he was paid and imply he had been complicit."
The calculation of it sat in the air for a moment.
"She thought of everything," I said.
"She thought of almost everything," Gerald said.
"She didn't think about Patricia.
She didn't think about the camera.
And she didn't think about a seventy-one-year-old man sitting on the Maine coast who has been losing sleep for four years."
I pressed my palm flat against the kitchen counter.
"Gerald," I said.
"What does Diane say about charges?"
"She's spoken to the DA's office.
Given the documented evidence — the ledger, the note, the deviation in your treatment records, and now Krauss's declaration — they are prepared to open a formal investigation." He paused.
"That's separate from the civil settlement.
The criminal inquiry runs on its own track."
"How long?"
"Months.
Possibly longer.
But it's open, Claire.
Once it's open, it doesn't close quietly."
I looked out the kitchen window.
It was dark outside, and the glass gave back my own reflection — a woman standing very still in a lit room.
"There's one more thing," Gerald said.
"Ethan called me today."
"I know.
He called me too.
I didn't pick up."
"He knows about Krauss," Gerald said.
"I'm not sure how.
Possibly through the family attorney.
He asked me directly if his mother had interfered with your treatment."
"What did you tell him?"
"That it wasn't my place to answer that question," Gerald said.
"That he should speak to you."
I was quiet.
"You don't have to," Gerald said.
"He's not entitled to a conversation."
"No," I said.
"He's not." I paused.
"But I think I need to have it anyway.
Not for him.
For me."
Gerald said he understood.
After we hung up, I stood in the kitchen for a while longer.
Two miscarriages.
Two quiet rooms in the middle of the night with Ethan's arms around me and Margaret's sympathy delivered the next morning in fresh-cut flowers.
She had sent flowers.
I thought about that for a moment.
Then I went to the sink, washed my hands, dried them, and called Ethan back.
He picked up on the first ring.
"I need to see you," he said.
"Not about the settlement.
Not about the lawyers.
I need to see you as a person."
"Tomorrow," I said.
"Noon.
There's a coffee shop on Clement Street.
Come alone."
He said he would.
May you like
I ended the call and set the phone face-down on the counter.
Through the window, the dark outside was very wide.