Spotlight

Chapter 6: What Patricia Knew

I stepped further from the front door, away from the guests still filtering out behind me.

"How did you get this number?" I said.

"Gerald Marsh," Patricia said.

"He interviewed me six months ago.

He said if I ever had more to share, I should call you directly." A pause.

"I wasn't ready then."

"And now?"

"Margaret fired me three weeks ago.

Said she was reducing household staff." Another pause, shorter.

"The day before she fired me, I made a copy of something I probably shouldn't have.

I've been sitting with it since then trying to decide what to do."

"What did you copy?" I said.

"A second set of books," she said.

"Not the household accounts.

Separate.

Handwritten ledger, kept in the bottom drawer of the library desk.

Margaret didn't know I'd seen it.

I was looking for a stapler."

I turned away from the driveway and kept my voice very even.

"What kind of entries?"

"Payments," Patricia said.

"Going back eight years.

To a law firm I'd never heard of, and to two other names.

Monthly amounts.

Significant ones." She hesitated.

"And receipts, mixed in with the pages.

One of them was from a medical clinic.

A fertility clinic."

My hand tightened around the phone.

"Patricia," I said carefully, "what was the date on the receipt?"

She told me.

Four years ago.

Seven months before my second miscarriage.

I stood very still on the steps of the house that was legally mine, in the cool dark, while a hundred small things I had never been able to explain rearranged themselves quietly inside my mind.

"Can you meet me tomorrow?" I said.

"Yes," she said.

"I've been hoping someone would ask."

---

We met at a coffee shop twelve miles from the Whitmore neighborhood — far enough that no one would see us, close enough that Patricia could drive it without anxiety.

She was in her late fifties, small, with careful eyes and the kind of stillness that comes from years of watching a household and learning to be invisible inside it.

She set a manila envelope on the table between us and kept her hand on it for a moment before letting go.

"I need to know I'm protected," she said.

"Before I say anything else."

"My attorney can arrange a formal witness declaration," I said.

"You'll be protected."

She nodded and lifted her hand.

I opened the envelope.

The ledger pages were photocopied — crisp, clean, the handwriting on them unmistakably Margaret's.

Columns.

Dates.

Amounts.

Names abbreviated to initials on most lines, but not all.

One entry was not abbreviated.

*Dr.

Ellison Krauss.

Consultation re: hormone protocol.

Per M's instructions.

Do not invoice through standard accounts.*

I looked up at Patricia.

"Dr.

Krauss," I said.

"He was the clinic consultant," she said.

"The one who reviewed your treatment files before you started the second round.

Margaret arranged the referral.

She said she wanted to make sure you were getting the best care."

"She said that to you?"

"To Ethan.

I overheard it." Patricia's voice was very quiet.

"I didn't understand what it meant at the time.

I thought she was being kind."

I set the page down.

Three fertility treatments.

Each one carefully monitored.

Each one recommended by a doctor that Margaret had hand-selected, had privately consulted, had paid through accounts that didn't appear in any standard ledger.

Two miscarriages.

"Patricia," I said.

"Did you find anything in those pages about the treatments themselves?

About the outcomes?"

She reached into the envelope and removed a single page.

Separate from the others.

She placed it face-down on the table and kept her fingers on it.

"This one I almost didn't bring," she said.

"Because once you read it, you can't unread it."

I turned it over.

It was a handwritten note.

Margaret's script, different from the ledger — faster, less controlled, like something written in a private moment rather than a formal entry.

*E.

confirmed.

Second protocol adjusted.

Outcome as expected.

Claire will not carry to term under these conditions.

She will give up eventually.

They all do.*

The coffee shop was warm.

Bright.

A couple at the next table was laughing about something on a phone.

I read the note twice.

"She knew," I said.

Not to Patricia.

To myself, mostly.

Just to hear it said aloud.

Patricia's eyes were red at the rims.

"I'm sorry," she said.

"I should have come forward sooner.

I didn't know what it meant until I read more carefully.

And by then I thought — I thought maybe I was wrong.

Maybe I was misreading it."

"You weren't," I said.

"No," she said.

"I wasn't."

I put the pages back in the envelope.

My hands were steady.

I was aware of them being steady in a way that meant some part of me was holding something very large very carefully, the way you carry something fragile when you cannot afford to drop it yet.

"I'll call my attorney," I said.

"Today."

Patricia nodded.

"There's one more thing," she said.

She reached into her coat pocket and put a small USB drive on the table.

"The library had a security camera.

Interior, for the art.

Margaret forgot about it two years ago when she updated the system.

May you like

The password was never changed." She looked at me steadily.

"I have eleven months of footage."

Related Stories

Other posts