Spotlight

Chapter 9: What Craig Hollis Said Next

The lawyer's name was Diane Farwell.

Her office was on the fourth floor of a building downtown that smelled like carpet cleaner and old coffee, and she met us in a conference room with a long table and windows that looked out over a parking structure.

She was fifty or so, direct, and she opened the meeting by looking at the manila envelope Dad set on the table and saying, "Let's see what we have."

She went through everything Teresa had provided.

She read the email.

She looked at the amended deposit record.

She read Craig Hollis's letter to Teresa and then she looked at the screenshot of his text to me.

She set them all face-up on the table in a row.

"All right," she said.

"Here's what I can tell you.

The realignment of the original deposit — and I'm being careful about how I phrase this because I want you to understand exactly what it is — constitutes fraudulent misrepresentation of an inherited asset.

That's not a civil inconvenience.

That's a criminal matter."

Dad looked at the pages.

"For Craig."

"For Craig, yes.

Potentially for Renee as well, depending on what she can be shown to have known and when." She tapped the email.

"This makes the 'when' fairly clear." She looked at me.

"The money from that account was held in trust for you.

It originated from a life insurance payout in your name as secondary beneficiary.

It was your money.

What was done to it was done to you."

I had known that.

I had been knowing it for two days.

But hearing someone say it in a room with a conference table and legal pads made it sit differently.

"The bag," I said.

"The bag is actually very useful," Diane said.

"Because it creates a provable chain.

Funds from a traceable account, moving through a traceable transfer, to a purchase with a dated receipt." She looked at Dad.

"Does she still have it?"

"As far as I know," he said.

"Good.

Don't let that change."

Dad's phone buzzed.

He looked at it and silenced it.

"Craig Hollis," he said.

Diane's eyebrows rose slightly.

"Has he contacted you directly?"

"Three times since nine this morning." Dad put the phone face-down.

"I haven't answered."

"Good.

Don't." She made a note.

"What he's doing right now is trying to understand the shape of what you know before you do anything formal with it.

He'll be calculating his exposure." She looked between us.

"I'd like to contact him, with your authorization.

Not to negotiate.

To inform him that you are represented and that further direct contact with you or your daughter should be routed through this office."

"Yes," Dad said.

She made another note.

Then she set her pen down and looked at me.

"I want to ask you something.

Not about the money.

About what happened the morning of your graduation.

With the dress."

I looked at her.

"That is a separate matter," she said.

"What Mia did is destruction of your personal property.

If you want to pursue that, we can.

It's smaller in scale, but it's documented — your father was present, and the physical evidence is still in that room." She paused.

"I want to make sure you're being asked.

Sometimes people aren't asked.

They get carried along by the larger thing and their specific piece of it doesn't get addressed."

The room was quiet.

I thought about the carpet.

The beads.

The forty seed pearls I had sewn back on myself the night I brought the dress home, because one strap had come loose and I didn't want to make it a big deal.

"I want it addressed," I said.

"Good." She wrote something down.

"We'll address it."

Her assistant knocked and opened the door.

Handed her a folded note.

She read it, refolded it, and set it to the side.

"Craig Hollis," she said, "has just retained an attorney.

That was fast." She looked neither surprised nor concerned.

"It means he was already prepared for this.

Which means he knew it was coming." She picked up her pen again.

"Which tells us something."

"That he's been waiting," I said.

"That he's been ready," she said.

"There's a difference.

Ready suggests he has a counter-position already prepared.

Something he thinks changes the picture." She looked at the email on the table.

"We have the email.

He knows we have the email because Teresa no longer has any reason to protect him.

So whatever his counter-position is, it has to account for that."

Dad said, "What would that look like?"

"He might claim the amendment was authorized.

That you signed something that gave implicit consent to the restructure." She looked at Dad directly.

"Did you sign anything, in those first two years of marriage, related to financial consolidation or account management, that you didn't read carefully?"

Dad was very still.

"There was a document," he said slowly.

"Renee had a financial consolidation form.

She said it was for the household accounts."

"Do you remember signing it?"

"Yes." His voice had gone flat again.

"I remember thinking it was a lot of pages for something routine."

Diane looked at him.

"And you signed it."

"I signed it." He looked at the table.

"I signed it because I trusted her."

"Of course you did," Diane said.

Not unkindly.

"That's the whole thing.

That's always been the whole thing."

The same words.

From the email.

*He trusts you completely.

That's the whole thing.

That's always been the whole thing.*

Dad heard it too.

I watched the recognition move across his face, and then close down, quiet and cold.

"Whatever I signed," he said, "doesn't make forty-two become twenty-one legitimate."

"No," Diane said.

"It doesn't.

But it may complicate the timeline.

Which is why we need a forensic accountant this week." She was already writing the name on a notepad.

"She's very fast and very thorough.

I'll send her your folder today." She tore the page off and pushed it across to Dad.

Then she looked at both of us.

"They thought they had a clean exit," she said.

"They were wrong.

The exit has Teresa on it, and Teresa had the sense to make copies." She gathered the pages into a neat stack.

"Let's go get your money back."

Outside, in the parking structure elevator, Dad held the door for an elderly man with a walker and we all rode down to street level in silence and then the man said, without looking at either of us, "Whatever it is, it'll come out right.

These things do."

The doors opened.

He moved off slowly toward the street.

Dad watched him go.

"You believe that?" I asked.

He thought about it.

"I'm starting to," he said.

His phone rang again as we reached the car.

He looked at the screen.

Put it in his pocket without answering.

But before he did, I saw the name on the screen.

It wasn't Craig.

May you like

It wasn't Renee.

It was Mia.

Related Stories

Other posts