Spotlight

Chapter 12: Settlement Refused

Craig Hollis made the offer on a Friday.

Diane called while Dad and I were eating the pasta — she actually called during dinner, which she had said she would only do if something time-sensitive moved — and Dad put her on speaker and set the phone between us on the table.

"He's offering full restitution of the twenty-one thousand," she said.

"Plus an additional eight thousand in what he's calling a goodwill payment.

He wants a signed agreement that you won't cooperate with any criminal investigation and that you'll characterize the consolidation document as a mutual misunderstanding."

Dad looked at the phone.

"He wants us to tell the DA's office it was a misunderstanding."

"In writing," Diane said.

"So that he can use it to defend himself against the other two cases," I said.

A pause.

"That's my reading, yes."

Dad picked up his fork.

Set it back down.

"Tell him no."

"I already did," Diane said.

"I wanted you informed.

He'll likely come back with a higher number."

"The number doesn't change the answer," Dad said.

"I know," Diane said.

"But he doesn't know that yet.

Give him a day to figure it out."

She ended the call.

Dad looked at his plate.

"Eat," I said.

He picked up his fork.

We ate.

Outside the kitchen window the bird feeder was finally full — Dad had filled it two days ago, standing on the back step in the early morning before the rest of the day started, and a pair of sparrows had found it by noon and hadn't left it alone since.

"I should have looked at the document," he said.

Not for the first time.

Not angrily.

"He counted on you not looking," I said.

"That doesn't absolve me of not looking."

"No," I said.

"But it tells you whose fault it is."

He was quiet for a moment.

"She seemed so organized," he said.

"After your mother — after everything, this house was a lot.

And she came in and she was calm and she knew how to do things and she made it easier." He looked at his plate.

"I was so relieved to have someone who knew how to do things."

"I know," I said.

"I should have protected that account better."

"You protected it for six years," I said.

"From yourself.

You never touched it.

You let it sit there with her name on it because it wasn't yours." I paused.

"That's not carelessness.

That's love.

Someone took advantage of love."

He looked at me.

"That's different," I said.

"That matters."

He didn't say anything.

He reached over and topped up my water glass from the pitcher, which was something he had done my entire life, and then he sat back and we ate the rest of dinner without talking, and it was the most normal half hour either of us had had in two weeks.

Craig Hollis came back on Monday with thirty thousand and a softened version of the agreement.

Diane said no.

He came back on Wednesday with the full forty-two eight hundred, plus interest, plus legal fees.

Diane said the answer was still no, and that her clients were cooperating fully with the financial crimes investigation, and that further settlement inquiries should be directed to the DA's office.

He did not call again after that.

The DA's office filed charges on a Thursday morning — financial fraud, elder financial @buse, and fraudulent misrepresentation of an inherited asset.

The charges covered Craig Hollis and named Renee as a co-respondent.

Diane called while I was in a coffee shop two blocks from the garden center on Route 9.

I stepped outside to take it.

"It's filed," she said.

"What happens now?"

"He'll be required to appear.

He'll almost certainly post bail.

The process is slow." A pause.

"But it's moving."

I stood on the sidewalk outside the coffee shop.

The same coffee shop I had walked past every Friday for five months, four dollars in my pocket that I'd decided to keep.

The door opened behind me and a woman came out with a cup in each hand, said "excuse me" as she passed, and moved on.

"Diane," I said.

"The money — is there a realistic chance we actually get it back?"

"His assets are being reviewed as part of the investigation," she said.

"The shell LLC has accounts attached to it.

We've filed a civil claim alongside the criminal referral.

A lot depends on how the case proceeds." A pause.

"But yes.

There's a realistic chance."

"Okay," I said.

"How are you doing?" she asked.

I looked at the coffee shop door.

Four dollars.

Five months.

"I'm okay," I said.

May you like

"I'm actually okay."

After I hung up, I went inside and ordered a coffee — not the cheapest thing on the menu, not the most expensive, just the one I wanted — and I sat at the counter by the window and drank it, and watched the street, and let myself be somewhere ordinary on a day when something was finally moving in the right direction.

Related Stories

Other posts