Chapter 7: Nine O'Clock

Patricia Wren was fifty-one, wore her gray hair short, and had the kind of stillness in a courtroom that made opposing attorneys nervous.
I had found her through a friend of Uncle Richard's — someone who had described her as "the person you call when the other side has already been planning for months."
She had been planning longer.
She met me outside Judge Alderman's courtroom at eight forty-five the next morning.
Uncle Richard was beside me.
Diane Hale had offered to come.
I had told her to stay available by phone.
"Walk me through Carver," I said.
"Mitchell Carver.
He's done three cases like this in the last two years — high-asset husbands contesting protective orders filed by wives.
He wins by volume.
He buries the other side in procedural motions until they run out of money or patience." Patricia held the door for me.
"He's counting on you being neither prepared nor funded."
"And we are both."
"We are both." She glanced at me.
"The envelope from Diane Hale is the piece he doesn't know about.
I want to hold it.
I don't want to use it unless he forces my hand today.
Let him show his argument first."
The courtroom was small and wood-paneled, the kind of room that smelled like old paper and central heating.
Bennett was already there, seated beside a man in a dark suit who I assumed was Carver.
Bennett looked up when I walked in.
His expression was controlled, but his eyes went to Patricia, then to the folder under her arm, then back to my face.
He was trying to read how much I had.
Judge Alderman entered at nine exactly.
She was in her sixties, with reading glasses on a chain and the manner of someone who had heard every variation of this story and was not interested in theater.
Carver stood.
"Your Honor, we're here on an emergency motion to vacate the protective order filed by Mrs.
Hale on the grounds that it was obtained through material misrepresentation.
Specifically, Mrs.
Hale failed to disclose to this court that she has been engaged in a pattern of financial conduct that directly contradicts her claim of economic vulnerability."
Judge Alderman looked at Patricia.
"Counselor?"
Patricia stood.
"Your Honor, Mr.
Carver's motion is built on a single bank statement from an account my client closed fourteen months ago.
The balance at closure was eleven thousand dollars.
He is characterizing this as evidence of hidden wealth.
We are prepared to provide complete financial records demonstrating that my client's current accounts were frozen unilaterally by her husband three days ago, leaving her without access to funds for basic medical care during the final weeks of a high-risk pregnancy."
Carver cut in.
"Your Honor, the account in question—"
"Mr.
Carver." Judge Alderman's voice was flat.
"You'll wait."
He sat.
Patricia continued.
"We are also prepared to introduce evidence that the protective order is not only warranted but insufficient, given what we have learned in the last eighteen hours about Mr.
Hale's conduct."
Carver was on his feet again.
"Your Honor, this is a procedural hearing.
Any new evidence would need to be—"
"Sit down, Mr.
Carver." Judge Alderman looked at Patricia.
"What evidence?"
Patricia opened her folder.
She placed three documents on the clerk's desk.
"A signed retainer agreement between Mr.
Hale and a second attorney, Gerald Fitch, for the purpose of pursuing annulment proceedings.
A letter of instruction to a private investigator hired to surveil Mrs.
Hale's daily movements and medical appointments.
And a document prepared at Mr.
Hale's direction outlining grounds for a psychiatric evaluation of Mrs.
Hale — to be used, we believe, to challenge her legal standing in custody proceedings."
The courtroom was quiet.
Judge Alderman picked up the third document.
She read it.
She set it down.
She looked at Bennett over the top of her reading glasses.
Bennett looked at Carver.
Carver's pen had stopped moving.
"Mr.
Carver," the judge said, "I'm going to need you to explain to me why I should not view this motion as an attempt to obstruct a legitimate protective order while your client was simultaneously preparing to undermine this court's jurisdiction."
Carver opened his mouth.
Closed it.
"That's what I thought," Judge Alderman said.
"Motion denied.
The protective order stands.
Mr.
Hale, I am expanding the order to include all joint and individual accounts pending a full financial disclosure hearing, which I am scheduling for—" She turned to her clerk.
"Three weeks."
Bennett's chair scraped back one inch.
Just one inch.
But I heard it.
"Your Honor," Carver said, recovering, "my client requests—"
"Your client," Judge Alderman said, "should spend the next three weeks getting his financial records in order.
Because I will be looking at all of them." She stood.
"We're adjourned."
I didn't look at Bennett when I stood.
I looked at Patricia.
"Three weeks," I said.
"Three weeks," she said.
"And now he knows we have the envelope."
My phone buzzed in my bag.
I took it out under the table.
A message from Bennett.
May you like
Four words.
*We need to talk.*