Chapter 7: The Option He Hadn't Considered

"What do you mean it's not an option?" David stepped into the kitchen.
"I'm telling you I want to work on this.
I'm telling you I made a terrible mistake and I want to fix it."
"You told me last night you don't know if you love her." Eleanor set her coffee mug on the counter.
"This morning you want to fix things.
Which one is true?"
"Both of them can be true."
"No.
They can't." She turned to face him.
"If you don't know what you feel about another woman after two years, then you don't want to fix your marriage.
You want to keep your life intact.
Those are very different things."
He opened his mouth.
"Don't," she said.
"I've been thinking about this since two in the morning for five days.
Please don't tell me something in the next thirty seconds that you decided in the car on the way home from school drop-off."
He closed his mouth.
She pulled out a chair and sat down at the table.
After a moment, he sat across from her.
"I've already spoken to a solicitor," Eleanor said.
"Not to file anything.
Just to understand my position."
His head came up.
"You what?"
"I needed to understand what the process looks like before we had this conversation.
That's not a threat.
It's information."
"Eleanor, if you've already gone to a lawyer —"
"I went to get facts.
The same way I went through your airline account to get facts.
The same way I read fourteen months of emails to get facts." She held his gaze.
"You have been lying to me for two years.
I needed facts because I couldn't trust what came out of your mouth."
He sat back.
The fight went out of him in a visible way — his shoulders dropped, his hands spread flat on the table.
"You're right," he said quietly.
"You're right."
"I know I'm right."
"What did the solicitor say?"
"That depends entirely on what you decide to do.
Which is why I'm asking you clearly, right now, with no one else in this house: do you want to end the relationship with Serena and genuinely try to repair this marriage — not because it's convenient, but because you actually want to — or do you want to go?"
He looked at her for a long time.
"What about Lily?" he said.
"Lily is not a bargaining position.
Whatever you decide, we will handle Lily together like adults.
She will not be punished for your choices or mine.
That is not up for discussion."
He nodded slowly.
"I don't want to lose you," he said.
"Or her."
"I didn't ask what you don't want.
I asked what you want."
He pressed both hands flat on the table.
"I want to end it with Serena," he said.
"I want to try."
Eleanor looked at him.
She had known this man for twelve years.
She had married him.
She had built a life in this house and raised their daughter in it and she knew, with a clarity that surprised her, that she believed him.
She also knew that believing him was not the same as trusting him.
"Then here is what happens next," she said.
"You end it today.
Not a phone call.
In person, or by written message that I see before you send it.
We begin marriage counseling this week — I already have a name.
You give me access to your phone and your email for as long as I need it, and you don't object to that or make me feel wrong for asking." She paused.
"And you tell me, right now, whether there is anything else I don't know.
Because if I find one more thing on my own, this conversation never happens again."
He was very still.
"There's one more thing," he said.
Her chest tightened.
"She's not just a colleague." He didn't look away.
"She asked me, two months ago, if I would consider leaving.
I told her no.
She didn't take it well." He swallowed.
"She sent an email to my personal account last week saying that if I didn't talk to her before the end of the month, she was going to contact you directly."
The kitchen was completely silent.
May you like
Eleanor picked up her phone from the table and stood up.
"Show me the email," she said.