Chapter 4: What She Found at 2 A.M.

Lily was asleep by eight-thirty.
David said he needed to make his call.
He took his phone to the back porch, and Eleanor heard the door slide shut behind him.
She sat on the edge of their bed and listened to the silence of the house.
Through the window she could see the yellow square of the porch light and the dark shape of him standing with one hand in his pocket, his head slightly bent, the phone against his ear.
He stayed out there for forty minutes.
Eleanor changed into her pajamas, washed her face, and got into bed.
When he came back inside he said the call had gone long — complicated budget numbers, he'd explain tomorrow — and kissed her on the forehead before turning off the lamp.
He was asleep in ten minutes.
Eleanor lay in the dark and stared at the ceiling.
At two in the morning she picked up her own phone from the nightstand and opened his airline account.
He'd given her the login years ago — she managed the family travel rewards points.
She had never used it for anything else.
She typed in the dates of his last trip.
Toronto, he'd told her.
Five days at the regional office.
The booking showed a return from Toronto, as he'd said.
But the outbound leg was different.
He hadn't flown to Toronto.
He had flown to Vancouver.
Eleanor sat up very slowly.
David's breathing didn't change.
She went back through the booking.
The outbound ticket was dated Monday — the day he had left.
Vancouver International.
One passenger.
He had checked in at 6:14 in the morning.
She put the phone face-down on her knee and sat there in the dark for a moment, very still.
Then she picked it back up and opened his email.
She knew his password.
She had always known it.
They had never kept passwords from each other — that had always felt like the point, like proof of something.
She had never once opened his email before tonight.
She found it in less than two minutes.
A thread, labeled with a woman's name.
*Serena.*
Forty-one messages.
The most recent was timestamped eleven forty-three p.m.
— twenty minutes ago, while she'd been lying in this bed telling herself she was overreacting.
She didn't read all forty-one.
She read the first one, from fourteen months ago.
And then she read the most recent one.
The first one began: *I keep thinking about what you said at the conference.
I don't think I'm imagining it.*
The most recent one began: *Tonight was everything.
I'm already missing you.*
Eleanor set the phone on the nightstand.
She pressed both palms flat against her thighs and felt the cotton of her pajamas, the warmth of her own skin.
Fourteen months.
She thought about the last fourteen months.
The canceled weekends.
The late calls.
The trips that ran longer than planned.
She had believed every single explanation.
Not because she was foolish.
Because she had trusted him completely, and trust does not look for proof.
In the next room, Lily was sleeping.
The poster — *WELCOME HOME DAD* — was rolled up on the kitchen counter where Lily had left it.
Eleanor sat on the edge of the bed and looked at the dark shape of her husband and said nothing at all.
She would need to be very careful now.
She would need to think.
She reached over and picked up her phone one more time.
She opened a new note and typed one word.
*Serena.*
May you like
Then she turned the screen off, lay back down, and closed her eyes.
She did not sleep.