Chapter 8: The Deposition

Monday arrived the way important days often do — ordinary-looking, no particular announcement.
Patrick filed the deposition request at 9:02 a.m.
By 10:30, the Tampa firm had responded with a letter asserting attorney-client privilege and stating that their client — Harper — was prepared to dispute the validity of any claim that the deed transfer had been initiated without the property owner's awareness.
Patrick called to walk me through it.
"They're claiming you had awareness," he said.
"We expected that.
Here's what they didn't expect: I've already requested the full email record between the firm and all parties connected to the filing.
Under discovery rules, they have to produce it.
Attorney-client privilege protects legal advice.
It does not protect evidence of a third party being deceived."
"And if the emails show that Harper specifically directed them to proceed without contacting me?"
"Then their privilege argument collapses," Patrick said.
"Because they weren't protecting a client's confidential communication.
They were participating in an undisclosed property action against a third party.
That changes the conversation significantly."
"For the firm too," I said.
"For the firm too," he confirmed.
Three days later, Patrick called again.
His voice was controlled but warm underneath it — the way it gets when something has gone exactly the way he'd calculated.
"The emails arrived this morning," he said.
"Do you want the summary or the details?"
"Both," I said.
"Harper contacted the firm fourteen months ago.
The initial instruction was to prepare a deed transfer from your name to Caleb's, to be completed at a date to be determined.
The firm asked, in writing, whether the current property owner had been informed.
Harper responded — in writing — that you were elderly, that you often became confused about financial matters, and that it was in your best interest for the family to manage the process on your behalf."
My hand went still on the counter.
"She told them I was confused," I said.
"She told them you were elderly and confused," Patrick said.
"She used those exact words to justify proceeding without contacting you."
The Gulf outside was blue and indifferent and permanent.
I was sixty-one years old.
I ran three miles twice a week.
I had managed my own finances, my own property, and my own life without assistance since I was twenty-nine.
I had raised a son alone and saved enough to buy a condo on the Gulf Coast and written my own curtains and planted my own flower pots and I was not confused.
"She said that so they wouldn't need my signature," I said.
"She said that so they could argue, if challenged, that they acted reasonably given what they'd been told," Patrick said.
"It's called creating cover.
She gave them a reason to proceed that, if accepted, would shift the liability to her and away from them." He paused.
"The firm is reconsidering its position considerably."
"What do they want?"
"They want to provide a full cooperative statement in exchange for not being named in any formal action," Patrick said.
"They'll document everything.
Harper's instructions.
The timeline.
The representations she made about your mental state."
"That representation," I said slowly, "is potentially defamatory."
"It is potentially a great many things," Patrick said.
"Let's start with the property and work forward from there."
I sat down.
I hadn't realized I'd been standing.
"How does Caleb factor into this?"
"Caleb signed the initial intake paperwork as the proposed recipient," Patrick said.
"But the emails show he was brought in after the filing was already designed.
Harper sent him a summary email describing it as routine estate planning and asking him to sign a form she described as administrative.
He didn't have the full file." A pause.
"He didn't know what he was signing, Barbara."
The relief of that — clean and immediate — surprised me with its force.
I'd told myself I believed him.
But believing and knowing are different rooms.
"Thank you," I said.
"There's one more thing," Patrick said.
"Richard."
"Tell me."
"The emails reference a call between Harper and Richard three weeks before the Tampa filing was initiated.
The subject line of her follow-up email to the firm references, quote, investor interest pending title confirmation." He let that land.
"She was lining up a buyer before the transfer was even filed."
The room was very quiet.
"She was planning to sell it," I said.
"Or to use it as collateral for a development deal with Richard's firm," Patrick said.
"We don't have the full shape of it yet.
But the intent was not to hold the property in your family's name.
The intent was to move it into a position where it could generate capital."
My property.
My condo on the Gulf with my flower pots and my iron table and the curtains I'd sewn on a borrowed machine because the room deserved to feel soft.
It was going to become a line item in a real estate development portfolio.
And I was going to be described as a confused elderly woman who couldn't manage her own affairs.
"Patrick," I said.
"Yes."
"What are our options?"
"We file a formal complaint with the state bar regarding the Tampa firm's conduct," he said.
"We document Harper's misrepresentations in a formal letter that creates a legal record.
We send that record to Caleb, to Richard, and to the firm.
And we make clear that any future attempt to initiate a transfer — by anyone — will result in immediate legal action." He paused.
"Additionally, I think you should consider filing a formal civil complaint against Harper personally, for the defamatory representation she made about your mental capacity."
"Would that hold?"
"It's in writing," Patrick said.
"In a legal communication, representing you as confused and unable to manage your affairs to justify excluding you from a decision about your own property.
Yes.
It holds."
"Do it," I said.
"All of it?"
May you like
"All of it," I said.
"I want the record complete."