Spotlight

Chapter 10: The Conversation Harper Didn't Win

She called Patrick instead of me, which meant she'd realized that calling me was no longer producing the responses she needed.

Patrick reported the conversation to me the following morning, professionally and completely.

"She proposed a settlement," he said.

"No formal complaints.

No bar referral.

She would sign a written acknowledgment that the deed transfer was initiated without your informed consent, and in exchange, you would withdraw all pending actions and agree to a period of no contact between yourself and her parents."

I set my coffee down.

"She wants me to agree to no contact with her parents."

"As part of the settlement, yes.

She's framing it as mutual.

Mutual space for all parties.

No contact going both directions."

"She's trying to keep Catherine away from me," I said.

Patrick was quiet for a moment.

"That would be my interpretation as well."

I thought about Catherine in the bedroom doorway.

Catherine packing her suitcase without being asked.

Catherine saying, quietly, *I'm sorry about the flower pots.* A woman who had watched her husband do this before.

A woman who had run out of energy to pretend she hadn't.

"No," I said.

"Tell her no."

"I already did," Patrick said.

"On your behalf."

"How did she respond?"

"She said she would take the complaints to a public platform if we pursued formal action.

She said she would post a detailed account of the situation to social media describing you as a difficult and litigious woman who was destroying her son's marriage out of jealousy."

I picked my coffee back up.

"She's going to post about me on social media."

"She's threatening to," Patrick said.

"It may be a genuine threat or it may be a bluff to see if you'll settle."

"It's not a bluff," I said.

"Harper doesn't threaten things she isn't prepared to do."

"That may be true," Patrick said.

"But everything she posts is subject to defamation law, and she is already on record — in a legal communication — misrepresenting your mental capacity.

A public post elaborating on that theme would compound the existing claim considerably."

"And if she does it anyway?"

"Then we add it to the complaint," Patrick said simply.

She posted that evening.

A long post, carefully worded in the way of someone who has spent an hour choosing each word for maximum impact and minimum legal exposure.

It described a family conflict.

A difficult mother-in-law.

A son caught between loyalty to his wife and manipulation from his mother.

It did not use my name.

It used enough identifying detail that anyone who knew us would recognize it immediately.

Caleb texted me within minutes of it going up: *I've seen it.

I'm so sorry.

I told her to take it down.*

I texted back: *Don't argue with her about it tonight.

Just let it sit.*

He replied: *She already turned the comments off.*

I texted Patrick.

He called back in four minutes.

"Screen-captured," he said.

"We've got it.

Time-stamped.

Preserved."

"Good," I said.

"There's something else," he said, and his voice shifted slightly into a register I recognized as preparation.

"Catherine Alderman called my office this afternoon."

My hand tightened slightly on the phone.

"Catherine called you."

"She asked if I was Barbara's attorney.

I confirmed.

She said she needed to speak with someone who could help her — not as a client, she was very clear about that, she's not asking for representation — but as a witness." He paused.

"She said she has emails between Richard and Harper going back two years.

She said she found them on a shared family account eight months ago and she didn't know what to do with them."

The room went very still.

"Two years," I said.

"Two years," Patrick confirmed.

"This has been planned for two years."

"That is what the emails may show," he said.

"She's willing to provide them.

She asked only one thing in return."

"What?"

"That you call her yourself," Patrick said.

"She said she'd rather hear your voice first."

I looked at the Gulf through the window.

Steady.

Unconcerned.

May you like

Keeping its own time as it always did.

"Give me her number," I said.

Related Stories

Other posts