Chapter 5: The Story Laura Told First

Daniel kept one arm around Nia.
“Who did you call?”
Laura held up her phone.
“Family Services.”
Evelyn’s eyes narrowed.
“Before the television was broken?”
“I called because Daniel installed a camera without telling me.”
“In the hallway,” Daniel said.
“After three things were damaged.”
Laura opened an email.
“I told them he records us, controls the money, and frightens the children.
A caseworker is coming.”
Rory clung to her.
“Is Dad going away?”
“That depends on how he behaves,” Laura said.
Daniel stood slowly.
“Don’t say that to him.”
A knock sounded at the front door.
Laura’s shoulders lowered, and for the first time since Evelyn arrived, she smiled.
“That will be Ms.
Patel.”
The woman at the door introduced herself and showed Daniel her identification.
She carried a slim folder and spoke without raising her voice.
“I need to make sure both children are safe.
I will speak to each adult and each child separately.”
Laura opened the door wider.
“Of course.
I have nothing to hide.”
Ms.
Patel sat with Nia in the dining room while Evelyn waited nearby.
Nia twisted the cuff of her yellow sweatshirt until the fabric bunched around her fist.
“Has anyone told you what to say to me?” Ms.
Patel asked.
“My mother says Dad is dangerous.”
“Do you believe that?”
Nia looked toward the closed door.
“Am I allowed to say no?”
“You are allowed to tell me the truth.”
“Dad gets serious when something breaks.
But Mom tells him I did it before he asks me.”
“How often?”
Nia placed four fingers on the table.
“Four times?”
“Four that Dad knows about.”
Ms.
Patel leaned forward.
“Are there others?”
“The bracelet.
Mom said I lost it.”
“Did you?”
“I never touched it.”
The front door opened again.
A woman’s hurried voice carried down the hallway.
“I came as soon as Daniel called.”
Laura answered sharply.
“Why is she here?”
Nia recognized Ms.
Harper, the counselor from her school.
She appeared in the dining-room doorway holding a sealed envelope.
“I’m here because Nia has visited my office seven times since September.”
Laura followed her in.
“Those conversations are private.”
“They are,” Ms.
Harper said.
“But Nia gave permission for me to share her drawings and written statements with Ms.
Patel.”
“You questioned my daughter without me?”
“Nia came to me because she was afraid.”
“Afraid of Daniel,” Laura said quickly.
Ms.
Harper looked at Nia.
“Would you like to answer that?”
Nia’s chair scraped as she moved closer to Evelyn.
“I was afraid Mom would find out.”
Laura’s face stiffened.
“Nia, think carefully.”
Ms.
Patel turned.
“Do not coach her.”
“I am reminding my child not to lie.”
Nia stood, though her legs shook.
“You told me to lie.”
Laura stared at her.
“You told me to say I broke the lamp.
You told me to say I threw the stone.
You told me Rory would get sick again if he was punished.”
“That is not what I said.”
“You said being upset could send him back to the hospital.”
Rory appeared behind Daniel.
“Mom tells me that too.”
Laura swung around.
“Go upstairs.”
“No,” Daniel said.
“Stay with me.”
Rory took his father’s hand.
“Mom says my heart is weak.”
Daniel looked at Ms.
Patel.
“His doctor cleared him three years ago.”
Ms.
Harper placed the envelope on the table.
“There is something else.”
She removed a drawing of a house.
Three figures stood together beneath the roof.
A fourth stood outside in yellow.
“What does this prove?” Laura asked.
“Nothing by itself,” Ms.
Harper said.
“That is why I brought Nia’s written explanation.”
She read the first line aloud.
“Mom says families are happier when difficult people leave.”
Laura snatched the page and tore it down the middle.
Ms.
Patel stood immediately.
“That document belongs to the school.”
“It is a child’s story.”
“It was evidence,” Daniel said.
“Was,” Laura replied.
Ms.
Harper calmly opened her bag and removed a second folder.
“That was a copy.”
Laura’s confidence faltered.
Ms.
Harper handed the folder to Ms.
Patel.
“The originals are at school.”
Ms.
Patel read in silence, then looked at Daniel and Laura.
“Until I complete my assessment, neither child will be left alone with Mrs.
Bennett.”
May you like
Laura’s phone slipped from her hand and struck the table.
Then Rory whispered, “I know where Grandma’s bracelet is.”