Chapter 3: The Things Nia Never Broke

Their mother released Rory and folded her arms.
“He’s six, Daniel.
Children say strange things.”
Daniel set the tablet on the table.
“Laura, he asked if Nia would be blamed again.”
“And you’re treating that like a confession?”
“I’m treating it like a question that needs an answer.”
Laura reached for the tablet.
Daniel pulled it away.
“Play the rest,” Nia whispered.
Laura turned sharply.
“You stay out of this.”
Daniel stepped between them.
“No.
Nia gets to speak.”
Nia wiped her cheeks with her sleeve.
“Rory broke the blue lamp too.”
“I did not!” Rory shouted.
“You pushed your truck into it.”
Laura pointed toward the stairs.
“That is enough.
Go to your room.”
“Which child?” Daniel asked.
Laura’s finger remained in the air.
“Which child are you sending away?”
“Nia is upsetting Rory.”
Daniel tapped the screen again.
The recording continued beneath the sound of the ball bouncing.
Rory’s voice came through clearly.
“Will Dad take her birthday money like last time?”
Laura’s recorded answer was quieter.
“Only if you keep your mouth shut.”
Daniel’s hand tightened around the tablet.
Nia stared at her mother.
“You said Dad took that money.”
“I used it to replace the lamp,” Laura said.
“Someone had to pay for it.”
“But Rory broke it.”
“You were watching him.”
“I was doing homework.”
“You are his older sister.
Families help each other.”
Daniel placed the tablet beyond Laura’s reach.
“Helping is not the same as paying for someone else’s mistakes.”
Laura laughed once, but the sound was thin.
“So now I’m the terrible mother because I expect responsibility?”
“You took eighty dollars from a ten-year-old.”
“It was family money.”
“Grandma Evelyn gave it to me,” Nia said.
“I was saving for art camp.”
Rory pressed himself against the sofa.
“Mom said Nia didn’t need it.”
Laura’s face changed.
“Rory, be quiet.”
“But you said—”
“Go upstairs.”
Daniel crouched in front of his son.
“Did you break the lamp?”
Rory looked at Laura.
“Look at me,” Daniel said.
“Did you break it?”
Rory’s lower lip trembled.
“The truck slipped.”
“And the kitchen window?”
“The ball slipped.”
Nia’s breath caught.
Daniel stood.
“You told me Nia threw a stone through that window.”
Laura moved closer to him.
“She left the ball where he could find it.”
“It was in the garage,” Nia said.
“He took it.”
Laura swung toward her.
“Why are you suddenly remembering all this?”
“I always remembered.”
“Then why didn’t you say anything?”
“I did.”
The room went still.
Nia pulled at the cuff of her sweatshirt.
“You told me nobody liked a girl who blamed her little brother.
You said Dad would think I was jealous.”
Daniel’s face lost its color.
“When did she say that?”
“After the window.
And after Grandma’s bracelet disappeared.”
Laura knocked the tablet from the table.
It struck the carpet without breaking.
Daniel reached for it, but Laura was already pressing buttons.
“What are you doing?” he demanded.
“Ending this ridiculous interrogation.”
The screen went dark.
“You deleted it,” Daniel said.
Laura dropped the tablet onto the sofa.
“There.
Now perhaps this family can stop tearing itself apart over a television.”
Daniel picked it up and tried to reopen the file.
A message appeared across the screen: RECORDING DELETED.
Laura lifted her chin.
“You have no proof now.”
From the open hallway, a woman’s voice answered her.
May you like
“Yes, he does.”
Grandma Evelyn stood in the doorway holding her phone.