Chapter 7: What the Second Camera Caught

I called my attorney the next morning.
Her name was Grace Heller.
I had used her twice before — once for a contract dispute, once for a property matter — and she was the kind of lawyer who asked exactly the right questions and then went very quiet while she thought.
I told her everything.
Start to finish.
The shirt.
The camera.
The texts.
Derek's threat about the law firm contact.
The late-night call from his attorney.
When I finished there was a pause on her end.
"You still have the phone?"
"Yes."
"Do not return it.
Do not delete anything.
Do not show it to anyone else before I see it.
Can you come in this afternoon?"
"Yes."
"Bring your father."
Dad sat across from Grace in her office that afternoon, his hands in his lap, his posture as straight as it had always been.
He walked her through the timeline of the previous eight months without drama, without embellishment.
Three incidents.
The first — the story told to Aunt Ruth.
The second — a broken glass in the kitchen that Mia had claimed he had thrown at her, which he had not, but which he had no way to prove.
The third — last night.
Grace listened.
She made notes.
Then she looked up.
"You installed the second camera after the first incident?"
"After the second," Dad said.
"By then I understood there was a pattern."
"And you didn't tell your son."
"I had no proof yet of what the pattern meant.
And I didn't want to ask him to choose between his wife and his father without giving him something real to stand on."
Grace looked at him for a moment.
"The second camera footage from last night.
Is it accessible remotely?"
"I can pull it on my phone."
"I'd like a copy.
Officially transferred to me so there's a clean chain of custody."
She turned to me.
"The contact at the law firm Derek mentioned — the one he said could provide the consultation paperwork.
I need to know which contact.
That is a serious breach of client confidentiality if true.
I'll be making inquiries."
"How serious?"
"Bar complaint.
Possible disbarment, depending on what they actually shared and with whom.
Derek Paulson using stolen privileged information as a threat constitutes attempted coercion." She clicked her pen closed.
"He made that threat on camera."
I had not said that out loud yet.
The full weight of it landed now.
"He didn't know about the second camera," I said.
"No," Grace said.
"He didn't." She allowed herself one small, dry pause.
"That was unfortunate for him."
She laid out the options clearly and without pressure.
I could pursue this criminally — the staged false accusation of my father was actionable, and Derek's threat potentially more so.
I could pursue it civilly.
I could use the footage and messages as leverage in divorce proceedings and leave the criminal question to the appropriate authorities once everything was documented.
"What happens to Mia?" I asked.
Grace looked at me steadily.
"That depends on what she does next.
Has she retained her own attorney?"
"I don't know."
"If she cooperates and provides testimony regarding Derek's role in planning and directing this — it changes her exposure significantly."
I thought of her sitting on the hallway floor.
*I know what I did.* The first honest thing she had said all evening.
"She might cooperate," I said.
"Then I'd encourage whoever she speaks to first to tell her that cooperation is in her interest." Grace set her pen down.
"In the meantime, I need everything forwarded to me by end of day.
The texts.
The camera footage.
Any other documentation you have."
We stood up to leave.
Dad stopped at the door.
"The man who called last night," he said.
"Derek's attorney.
Is it legal for him to make contact that way?"
"That depends on what was said and how it was framed," Grace said.
"What did he say?"
I told her.
She wrote it down word for word.
"Attempting to discourage a victim from contacting authorities by offering private arrangements." She looked up.
"I'll be following up on him as well."
Dad thanked her quietly and walked out into the corridor.
I stayed one moment longer.
"Is there any way Derek walks away from this cleanly?" I asked.
Grace looked at me.
"Not if that second camera footage is what you've described.
And not if the contact at your former firm actually shared privileged documents." She picked up her pen again.
May you like
"People make large mistakes when they believe no one is watching." She paused.
"Your father was watching."