Spotlight

Chapter 3: What My Father Never Told Me

The name on the screen was Derek Paulson.

My brother-in-law.

Mia's older brother.

A man I had known for four years, had eaten Christmas dinner with, had helped move furniture for when he bought his new house eighteen months ago.

I picked the phone up off the floor.

Mia moved fast.

"Don't touch that.

That's my phone."

"Then answer it."

She reached for it.

I held it back and watched Derek's name disappear as the call went to voicemail.

Four seconds of silence.

Then it rang again.

I looked at Dad.

"How many times has this happened?

The shirt.

The screaming.

How many times?"

Dad pressed his hands on his knees and stood up slowly from the step.

"Three times that I know of.

The first was eight months ago.

You were away for a work conference.

She told your aunt I had said something inappropriate to her at the kitchen table." He paused.

"Your aunt believed her."

"Why didn't you tell me?"

"Because I had no proof.

And because she is your wife." He said it quietly, without accusation.

"A father doesn't put his son in that position without proof."

The phone stopped ringing.

Then a text came through.

I could see the first line on the screen before Mia snatched it from my hand.

I had already read it.

*Is it done?

Did he believe it?*

The hallway felt very small suddenly.

I could hear the dinner downstairs, the sound of a pot being set on the stove by my mother who had no idea that four feet above her head, her husband had just been vindicated and her son's marriage had just cracked open like old concrete.

"Give me the phone, Mia."

"You had no right to read that."

"Give me the phone."

She clutched it against her chest.

Her face had changed.

The tears were gone.

What was underneath was something harder, something that had been waiting behind the crying the whole time.

"You don't understand what's happening here," she said.

"Then explain it to me."

She said nothing.

I turned back to Dad.

"The first time she did this.

The story she told Aunt Ruth.

Did anyone else hear it?"

"Your cousin Thomas was there."

"Does he still believe her?"

Dad looked at me steadily.

"Thomas never believed her.

He came to me privately the next day and told me something." He stopped.

"Tell me."

"He said he had seen Mia and Derek together.

In a car.

Parked outside a coffee shop two towns over." Dad's voice stayed level.

"Sitting very close.

For a long time."

The pot downstairs clanged against the stove again.

My mother called up from the kitchen.

"Dinner's almost ready.

Is everything alright up there?"

Mia's jaw tightened.

She looked at me with something close to a warning.

"Don't do this tonight," she said quietly.

"Not in front of your parents."

"You chose tonight.

Not me."

Her phone buzzed in her hand.

Another text from Derek.

She turned the screen away before I could see it.

But her thumb moved.

She was typing a reply.

I walked to the top of the stairs and called down.

"Mom.

Can you and Dad eat without us tonight?

We need a few minutes."

A pause from the kitchen.

"Of course, sweetheart.

Take your time."

I came back and looked at Mia.

She was still typing.

"Put the phone down."

She kept typing.

I reached over and took it out of her hand.

She grabbed for it.

I stepped back and read the screen.

Derek had sent three messages in the last two minutes.

*Is it done?

Did he believe it?*

*Mia.

Answer me.*

*If the old man talks, the whole thing falls apart.

You know that.*

My hands were steady.

I was surprised by how steady they were.

"What whole thing, Mia?"

She looked at the wall.

Her jaw moved but she said nothing.

"What is falling apart?"

Still nothing.

I scrolled up.

May you like

The messages went back six weeks.

And what I read in those six weeks of texts turned the quiet evening, the warm house, the sound of dinner being made by my unsuspecting mother — turned all of it into something I no longer recognized.

Related Stories

Other posts