Spotlight

Chapter 6: The Other Woman He Never Mentioned

Detective Solis came back at four in the afternoon.

He brought a folder this time.

He didn't open it immediately.

He set it on the table beside my bed and sat down across from me the way people sit when what they're carrying is heavy and they've learned not to drop it.

Jan had taken Eli to the family lounge at the end of the hall.

He'd gone without protest, which meant Jan had promised him something — probably food, probably the exact kind that I'd been trying to limit.

I was grateful to her for both things.

Diane was still in the room.

By some unspoken agreement between us, neither of us had asked the other to leave.

We were in this the same way now, from opposite ends, and there was a strange steadiness in having her there.

Solis opened the folder.

"Mr.

Calloway was in contact with a woman named Mara Finch.

That contact began approximately fourteen months ago." He turned a page.

"Ms.

Finch was pregnant.

The child was Mr.

Calloway's."

He said it plainly.

Not cruelly.

Just plainly.

"Mara Finch lost the baby at twenty-two weeks.

There were complications.

The pregnancy could not continue." He looked up at me.

"Ms.

Finch cannot carry children to term.

She has a documented condition.

She and Mr.

Calloway were aware of this by the time you entered your third trimester."

I didn't speak.

Something in me had gone very quiet, the way a room goes quiet just before a storm reaches it.

"We believe," Solis continued, "that Mr.

Calloway made arrangements with Paul Greer to switch the infants at birth.

Your daughter was to be placed with Ms.

Finch.

Ms.

Marsh's daughter was to remain with you."

Diane made a sound.

Just one.

Small and sharp, the same sound she had made hours earlier in this same room.

"He was going to raise her?" Diane's voice was very careful.

"My daughter.

He was going to raise her — with her?"

"That is what the evidence currently suggests."

"And my daughter." She stopped.

"The real one.

His.

Where is she?"

"Ms.

Finch's residence was visited this afternoon.

Your daughter was there.

She is safe.

She is being transported back to this facility now."

Diane pressed both hands over her face.

Her shoulders shook but she didn't make another sound.

I sat with that for a moment.

My daughter.

My actual daughter.

She had been in another woman's house, a woman who had not been told — or had not admitted — how she came to have her.

"Mara Finch," I said.

"Did she know?"

Solis paused.

Not the pause of a man being evasive, but of one being careful.

"That is currently under investigation."

"That's not an answer."

"No," he said.

"It isn't.

What I can tell you is that Ms.

Finch has given a voluntary statement.

Her account of what she was told differs significantly from what the evidence shows."

I looked at the folder.

"What does the evidence show?"

He turned three pages and placed one in front of me.

It was a printed text exchange.

The names at the top were LUKE and MARA.

I read it.

I read it twice.

The exchange was eight months old.

They were discussing the plan in detail that no one improvises.

Hospital timings.

Staff names.

Which unit.

Which shift.

What Diane would be told.

What I would be told.

And at the end, Mara had written: *She'll never know.

Women in that state believe anything.*

She had been talking about me.

I set the page down.

My hands were completely steady.

"I want to see my daughter," I said.

"She'll be here within the hour."

"And Luke?"

Solis closed the folder.

"Mr.

Calloway was formally arrested twenty minutes ago.

He's been charged with identity fraud and unlawful transfer of a child.

Additional charges are under review." He paused.

"He requested to speak to you before being transported.

We told him that was your decision."

I looked at the wall.

Then at the bassinet.

Then at the door.

"No," I said.

Solis nodded once.

He stood, gathered the folder, and was almost at the door when I spoke again.

"Detective." He turned.

"The nursing aide.

Paul Greer."

"Picked up this morning.

He's cooperating."

I nodded.

Something that had been braced inside my chest loosened, very slightly.

"Thank you," I said.

He left.

The room settled into its particular quiet.

Diane was looking at the bassinet.

The baby inside it — her baby, I now understood completely — was sleeping with one fist pressed against her cheek.

"I'm sorry," I said.

"I know that's not enough."

Diane lowered her hands from her face.

Her eyes were swollen, her face exhausted.

But her voice, when it came, was clear.

"I heard her cry," she said.

"Through the whole floor.

And I thought I was losing my mind.

That grief was making me hear things." She looked at me.

"You believed your son."

"He didn't give me room not to."

She almost smiled.

The edge of it.

May you like

"No," she said.

"He didn't."

Related Stories

Other posts