Chapter 5: What Luke Had Promised Someone

Jan arrived within the hour.
She didn't ask questions at the door.
She walked straight to me, put both arms around me, and stayed there long enough that I stopped trying to hold everything upright by myself.
When she pulled back, her eyes were bright, but her voice was level.
"Tell me what you need."
"Stay with Eli."
She looked at my son, who was still on the edge of the bed, still in his yellow shirt, still watching his father the way a person watches a car that has run a red light and not yet hit anything.
"Done," Jan said.
She sat beside him and said something low that I didn't catch, and Eli leaned into her shoulder exactly one inch.
That one inch was the most he'd allowed himself all morning.
The police had moved Luke to a separate room down the hall.
Carol had explained it as standard procedure, and Luke had gone without argument, which told me his lawyer had already called him back and told him to stop talking.
Officer Tran returned to my room with a second officer, older, plainclothes.
He introduced himself as Detective Solis.
"Mrs.
Calloway, I know you've already given a statement.
I want to ask you about something specific."
"All right."
"Your husband made three visits to the maternity floor in the forty-eight hours before your daughter was born.
Not to your room.
To the nursing station on the east corridor.
Do you know why?"
I stared at him.
"I was still admitted.
I was two buildings over in the high-risk unit for the last week of my pregnancy.
He came to see me every day."
"He did.
But those three visits weren't logged to your room." Solis kept his voice neutral.
"He spoke to a specific staff member each time.
A nursing aide named Paul Greer.
Mr.
Greer called in sick the morning after your daughter was born and hasn't returned to work."
The room felt very still.
"What are you saying?"
"I'm saying we'd like to know what your husband and Mr.
Greer discussed.
And whether you were aware of any prior relationship between them."
"I've never heard that name."
Solis nodded like that was the answer he expected.
Across the room, Diane looked up from her chair.
She had been quiet for a long time.
Now her eyes were fixed on Detective Solis.
"I have," she said.
Everyone turned.
Diane's hands were in her lap.
She pressed them flat against her knees.
"Paul Greer was the aide assigned to me when I was admitted.
He was there when —" She stopped.
Started again.
"He was the one who came to tell me my baby hadn't survived."
The words fell into the room one at a time.
"He came in alone," she said.
"No doctor.
No second staff member.
Just him.
He said there had been complications.
That it had happened fast.
That they had done everything they could." She looked down at her hands.
"I believed him.
Why wouldn't I believe him?"
Detective Solis was writing quickly now.
"Ms.
Marsh, did Mr.
Greer say anything else at that time?"
"He gave me a form.
A release form, he said, for — for the remains." Her voice thinned at the edges but held.
"I didn't read it properly.
I couldn't.
I just signed it."
"Do you remember what the form looked like?"
"It was one page.
There was a logo at the top but I don't remember which one." She paused.
"There was a line at the bottom.
A name already printed there.
I remember thinking it was strange, that someone else's name was on my form, but I thought I was confused from the medication."
"What name?" Solis asked.
Diane looked directly at me.
"Calloway," she said.
The word landed in the center of the room and didn't move.
Jan's hand found Eli's arm.
He didn't pull away.
I heard my own breathing.
In.
Out.
Steady.
This was not a mistake.
This was not a coincidence or a clerical error or a hospital mix-up that a lawsuit would eventually settle.
This had been built.
Piece by piece, visit by visit, one signed form by one grieving woman who had trusted a man in scrubs because what reason would she have not to.
Luke had planned this.
He had planned it before our daughter was even born.
The question I hadn't yet let myself ask pushed through now, quiet and specific and unavoidable.
Why?
What reason — what possible reason — did my husband have to take our daughter and give her to Diane, and take Diane's daughter and put her in our room?
I looked at Detective Solis.
"There's something you're not telling me yet," I said.
He held my gaze for a moment.
May you like
"We're still putting it together," he said.
"But yes."