Chapter 6: The Call He Wasn't Ready For

Sandra Fitch called G.
Bixler at 9:00 the next morning.
I know this because Bernard called me at 9:47 and told me.
Bernard had also spoken to Sandra that morning.
She had called him first, to confirm a detail about the Fort Benning processing date, and mentioned that she was calling G.
next.
Bernard stayed on the line with me while we waited.
He told me more about Mack while we waited.
He said Mack had been quiet in the mornings and loud in the evenings, which made him easy to room with.
He said Mack had carried a photograph of me in his left breast pocket from the first week of training.
He said he had never seen Mack lose his temper except once, when another soldier said something dismissive about the Grenadian civilians they were there to protect.
He said Mack had looked at the man the way a door closes — firm, final, without anger, just shut.
I had to put the phone down for a moment after that.
When I picked it back up, Bernard said, "You doing all right?"
"Yes," I said.
"He was a good man," Bernard said.
"He deserved better than having someone else wear his service."
"Yes," I said again.
Sandra called me at 10:22.
"He hung up," she said.
"How far into the call?"
"Four minutes.
I identified myself, confirmed I was working on a follow-up to the Banner story, told him I had documentation from Army Records and a statement from a named veteran who was present at Fort Benning in October 1983.
I read him the language from Captain Adler's letter and asked him to respond."
"What did he say before he hung up?"
"He said the letter was a forgery.
He said Bernard Kaminsky was a confused old man.
He said his family had legal representation and that the Post-Gazette would be hearing from his attorney." Sandra paused.
"Then he hung up."
"Will that stop publication?"
"No.
We've got the Army Records documentation.
We've got Bernard on record.
We've got the original photograph and the handwritten identification on the back.
His attorney can send a letter.
It won't change the facts."
"When does the story run?"
"Friday morning.
Six days before the parade."
I exhaled.
"There's something else," Sandra said.
"After he hung up, someone from that household called the Banner.
Asked Dale Prentiss to pull the original story — said it had been published in error and the family would be pursuing a correction through legal channels."
"What did Dale say?"
"He said he'd already submitted a correction to run alongside my story on Friday and that the digital caption had been updated as of this morning."
The digital caption had been updated.
I pulled up the Banner's website on Vela's laptop.
The story was still there.
The photograph was still there.
But the caption now read: *Left to right: Sgt.
First Class Mack Colton, Bernard Kaminsky, unidentified, unidentified.
Point Salines, Grenada, October 1983.
Caption corrected November 29.*
*Photo courtesy of the Colton family.*
I read it three times.
Vela came to look over my shoulder.
Neither of us said anything for a moment.
Then my phone rang.
Ashlin.
I answered on the second ring.
"How could you do this?" Her voice was shaking.
Not with sadness.
With something harder.
"This is my father.
This is our family.
You are destroying my father's reputation over a photograph that was hanging in my house."
"In Mack's house," I said.
"With Mack's furniture and Mack's grandchildren and twenty months of Mack's wife's cooking and labor."
"That is not — this is not about that."
"Ashlin," I said.
"The caption is wrong.
Your father was not in that photograph.
He was not in Grenada.
Those are facts.
They can be verified.
I didn't create them."
"He is going to be humiliated in front of this entire town."
"I know," I said.
"That part is hard.
I'm sorry for that part."
She went quiet.
When she spoke again, her voice had dropped.
"You're not going to stop."
"No," I said.
"I'm not."
She hung up.
Vela straightened up behind me.
"She'll go to Zach," Vela said.
"Yes."
"Zach will come here."
"Probably tonight," I said.
Vela pulled out the chair beside me and sat down.
"What do you need?" she asked.
"I need to know Kinley is all right," I said.
My phone was already in my hand.
I typed to Kinley:
*You okay?*
Three minutes passed.
Then: *Grandpa G is really mad.
He keeps going in the garage.
Grandma Edy is crying.
Dad came home from work early.*
Then: *Grandma.
He said something about you.
Something bad.*
I typed back: *What did he say?*
Her reply came fast.
May you like
*He said, "That woman thinks she's won something.
She hasn't even seen what I can do yet."*