Chapter 4: What Gerald Knew
I didn't sleep that night.
Chloe fell asleep in the car on the way home, her yellow bow finally giving up entirely, her head against the window.
I carried her inside and tucked her in without waking her.
Then I sat at my kitchen table with a glass of water I didn't drink and my phone face-down in front of me, and I waited for something — I didn't know what.
A call.
A message.
The feeling that I understood what had just happened.
None of it came.
At seven the next morning, my phone rang.
Unknown number.
I almost didn't answer.
"Valerie Hargrove?" A woman's voice.
Brisk, professional.
"Yes."
"My name is Dana Cho.
I'm a civil litigation attorney.
Logan Montgomery asked me to reach out to you directly." A brief pause.
"He thought you might need independent representation.
Given the circumstances."
I looked at Chloe's backpack hanging by the door.
Her library book was sticking out of the top pocket.
A chapter book about a girl who discovers a hidden garden.
"What circumstances exactly?" I said.
"The forged power of attorney.
The irregular will amendment.
The property transfers." Another pause, shorter this time.
"Ms.
Hargrove, if the original will holds — and based on what Arthur Briggs has already filed, there's a strong argument that it will — you are entitled to half of everything your father left.
The Newport property.
The estate accounts.
The investment portfolio."
I sat very still.
"That's a significant amount of money," Dana said.
"How significant?"
"The Newport property alone appraised at four point two million last year.
The full estate, including the accounts and the portfolio, is closer to nine."
The glass of water was still in front of me.
I picked it up and put it down again without drinking.
"I need you to understand," Dana continued, "that this will not be simple.
Your mother and Gerald Marsh will fight this.
Gerald has already retained his own counsel — we found out this morning.
And Rachel's position is complicated because she had partial knowledge of the LLC structure, even if she claims she didn't know about the forged signature."
"She said she didn't know about the signature."
"People say a lot of things." Dana's voice wasn't unkind.
"What matters is what we can prove.
And right now, what we can prove is substantial." A pause.
"Will you meet with me?"
I said yes before I fully decided to.
We met that afternoon at a coffee shop three blocks from Chloe's school.
Dana Cho was small, precise, and carried a leather notebook that she opened immediately.
She was younger than I expected — early forties, maybe — with the particular energy of someone who had never once in her career been talked out of something she believed.
"Walk me through the USB drive," she said.
"Everything Chloe found, where she found it, how long she had it."
I told her.
All of it.
The tablet case.
The three days Chloe had carried it.
The moment at the DJ booth.
Dana wrote without looking up.
"The recording is admissible in New York as long as one party to the conversation consented to the recording.
Chloe's tablet recorded passively — she wasn't present in the room.
That's a one-party consent question we'll need to address." She looked up.
"But the recording is corroborating evidence, not the foundation.
The foundation is the forged signature and the irregular notarization.
Those stand on their own."
"What happens to Gerald?"
Dana set her pen down.
"Gerald Marsh forged a power of attorney on a d*ceased man's behalf and used it to transfer property worth millions.
That's not a civil matter." She said it plainly.
"That's fraud.
Potentially worse, depending on what else we find."
"What else might we find?"
"That's what I want to talk to you about." She opened to a new page.
"Your father's d*ath.
The timeline, the circumstances, the estate administration immediately afterward.
I want to understand everything that happened in the six months after he passed."
I looked at her.
"You think there's more," I said.
"I think Gerald Marsh didn't forge a document and risk his entire career and his freedom for a woman he'd known for thirty years without a very compelling reason." She held my gaze.
"I want to know what that reason was."
I thought about my father.
Edward Hargrove.
A quiet man who had loved his garden and his books and both his daughters equally, even when one of them had been told her whole life that he hadn't.
He had d*ed of a cardiac event on a Tuesday in March, three years ago.
I had been at work.
Rachel had been the one to call me.
Rachel had been the one to handle everything afterward.
"Rachel managed the estate administration," I said slowly.
"She said it was easier because she lived closer to Mom.
I was grateful.
I had just gone through my divorce and I had Chloe and I couldn't—" I stopped.
"I trusted her."
Dana nodded.
She wrote something down.
"I need you to get me anything you still have from that period," she said.
"Any correspondence.
Any documents your mother or Rachel sent you.
Any emails about the estate, the will, the property.
Anything at all."
"I have some emails."
"Good." She closed the notebook.
"One more thing." She looked at me carefully.
"Your mother is going to call you.
Possibly today, possibly tomorrow.
When she does, do not discuss the case.
Do not argue.
Do not try to understand her reasoning or give her an opportunity to explain herself." A pause.
"Just tell her to contact your attorney."
My phone buzzed on the table between us.
We both looked at it.
Theresa.
Dana watched my face.
"You don't have to answer."
I looked at my mother's name on the screen.
I thought about the recording.
About her voice — calm, almost cheerful — saying there was nothing I could do.
That I had no money, no lawyer, no one who would believe me.
I picked up the phone.
"I have an attorney now, Mom," I said.
"Her name is Dana Cho.
You can reach her at—"
"Valerie, stop." My mother's voice was different.
The authority was still there, but underneath it was something I had never heard before.
Something that sounded almost like fear.
"Before you do anything, there are things you don't understand.
Things about your father.
About why Gerald—"
"Mom."
"—about why it had to be done this way, there were debts, Valerie, your father had debts that nobody knew about and if the estate had gone through probate the way it was supposed to—"
"Mom." I kept my voice even.
"Call Dana Cho.
I'm not discussing this with you."
I hung up.
Dana was watching me.
She didn't say anything for a moment.
"You said she'd call today," I said.
"I did."
"She said my father had debts.
That nobody knew."
Dana wrote it down.
"That's new information," she said.
"And it's the kind of thing people say when they're building a defense." She looked up.
"It may also be true.
We'll find out." She closed the notebook.
"Either way — it doesn't justify what they did to you."
Chloe's school was two blocks away.
I could see the top of the building from the coffee shop window.
"My daughter carried that drive for three days," I said.
"She's eight.
She knew something was wrong and she carried it alone because she thought I'd make her delete it." I looked at Dana.
"She was protecting me."
Dana's expression shifted — just slightly.
The professional precision softened at the edges.
"Then let's make sure it was worth carrying," she said.
Her phone rang.
She glanced at it and her jaw tightened slightly.
"It's Arthur Briggs," she said.
She looked up at me.
"Gerald Marsh's attorney just contacted Logan's team."
"Already?"
May you like
"Gerald wants to make a deal," Dana said.
"And he says he has documents that Theresa doesn't know he kept."
