Spotlight

Chapter 4: Both Keys

Ruth left an hour later.

She hugged me at the door and didn't say anything about Daniel, which told me more than any words would have.

He was still at the kitchen island when I came back inside.

The bag and the card and the photograph were still on the counter between us like evidence at a trial neither of us had agreed to attend.

"When did you give her both keys?" I asked.

"Before we moved in."

"Before we moved in." I repeated it back to him so he could hear it.

"So from the beginning."

"She lives alone, Cass.

If something happened to her—"

"That's what phones are for.

That's what neighbors are for.

A spare key for emergencies goes with someone who respects that it is for emergencies." I looked at him steadily.

"Your mother used it to come into this house while I was sleeping and leave clothes for our baby with a different name."

"She got excited.

She didn't think—"

"She thought very clearly.

She has been thinking very clearly this entire time." I sat down across from him.

"She moved things in the nursery.

She left her mug.

She left a photograph behind the nappy basket where I might not find it for months.

That is not someone who got carried away.

That is someone who is marking territory."

Daniel rubbed the back of his neck.

"You're making it sound deliberate."

"Because it is deliberate."

"She loves this baby."

"She pushed me, Daniel."

He stood up from the island.

"It was—"

"Don't." I said it quietly.

"Do not say that word to me again."

He stopped.

He looked at the floor.

His hands went into his pockets.

"I need both keys back," I said.

"Tonight.

And I need you to call her and tell her she is not to enter this house unless one of us opens the door for her."

"She'll be hurt."

"Good."

That came out harder than I intended, but I didn't soften it.

He looked up at me.

"Cass—"

"She put her hands on my shoulders and I fell next to our daughter's crib.

I sat on that floor for several seconds not knowing if our baby was okay.

And your mother's first response was to protect herself, and your first response was to protect her." I pressed my palms flat on the island.

"I have been very patient, Daniel.

I have tried very hard to be fair.

But I am eight months pregnant and there is a woman letting herself into this house whenever she feels like it, and you knew.

You knew the whole time, and you let me wonder whether I was remembering wrong."

Something moved across his face.

Not quite guilt.

Closer to the expression a person makes when they realize the story they have been telling themselves doesn't hold together anymore.

"I'll get the keys," he said.

"When?"

"Tonight.

I'll go over there tonight."

"I'm coming with you."

He looked up sharply.

"That's not a good idea."

"Why not?"

"Because you two together right now—"

"Your mother has been in my home twice without permission.

The second time I was alone and asleep.

I have every right to be there when you retrieve the keys." I held his gaze.

"Unless there's something at her house you don't want me to see."

That landed.

I watched it land.

"There's nothing," he said.

But his hand went to his phone before he finished the sentence.

"Who are you texting?"

"I'm not texting anyone."

I walked around the island.

He turned the phone slightly — not enough to hide it, just enough that the gesture itself told me everything.

I reached out and put my hand over his.

"Daniel.

Who are you warning?"

He pulled the phone back.

"I'm not warning anyone, Cass.

I'm just — I wanted to tell her we were coming so she's not caught off guard."

"Show me."

He looked at me for a long moment.

Then he set the phone on the counter between us, screen up.

The message he had started read: *Mum, she wants to come.

Don't—*

He hadn't sent it yet.

I read it once.

Then I stepped back from the counter, picked up my own phone, and called my sister.

"Ruth," I said when she answered.

"Are you still nearby?"

"Five minutes away.

What happened?"

"I need a witness.

Can you meet us at Patricia's house in twenty minutes?"

Ruth didn't ask why.

"I'll be there," she said.

I ended the call and looked at Daniel.

His face had gone the color of old chalk.

"She's going to make this very difficult," he said.

May you like

"She already has," I said.

"We're just finally talking about it."

Related Stories

Other posts