Chapter 10: What Carol Did

Carol was forty-three, four years older than Daniel, and she had spent most of her adult life living in another city specifically, as she had once told me over a glass of wine, so that she and their mother could have a relationship that didn't require proximity.
I had always liked Carol.
I understood her better now.
She spoke to Daniel for eleven minutes.
I timed it because I was sitting at the kitchen table and the clock was directly in my eyeline and counting seconds was the only thing that kept me from replaying the image of Renee's photograph — two cups, a shared plate of cake, and Patricia's single-word comment underneath.
*Always.*
When Daniel handed the phone back his face was the careful kind of neutral that means a great deal has just been said.
"She's driving over," he said.
"To Patricia's?"
"Yes."
"Tonight?"
"She's already in the car."
Carol arrived at Patricia's house before either of us.
I knew because she called me from the driveway.
"Is Renee still there?" I asked.
"There's a car I don't recognize out front," she said.
"I'm going in."
"Carol—"
"Cass.
I have been watching my mother manage Daniel his entire life.
I have been watching it from a safe distance because that was the only way to keep a relationship with her." Her voice was flat and focused.
"I should have said something sooner.
I'm saying it now."
She hung up.
Daniel looked at me.
"Should we go over?"
"Carol asked us to let her go first," I said.
"Give her twenty minutes."
We sat in the kitchen.
Daniel made tea that neither of us drank.
I put one hand on my stomach and my daughter moved slowly under my palm, and that small continuous movement was the most grounding thing in the room.
Carol called back in eighteen minutes.
"Renee is leaving," she said.
"I explained the situation to her.
She was—" A pause.
"She's not a villain, Cass.
She's just a sad person who my mother has been keeping emotionally attached to a grief that should have been allowed to heal years ago."
"What do you mean?"
"My mother has been calling Renee regularly since she found out the truth about how far along the pregnancy was.
Not weekly.
But enough.
She sent her things.
Cards on the anniversary.
She told me just now — she thought she was being kind.
She thought Renee needed someone." Carol exhaled.
"What she was actually doing was keeping a wound open so that there was always a version of Daniel's history that I think, on some level, she preferred to his present."
I sat with that.
"Where is Patricia now?" Daniel asked.
He had moved closer to me and I had tilted the phone slightly so he could hear.
"She's in the sitting room," Carol said.
"We need to talk to her together.
All of us.
Can you come over?"
Daniel looked at me.
This time I didn't hesitate.
"We're on our way," I said.
Patricia was seated on her sofa when we arrived.
She looked smaller than usual, or perhaps I was finally seeing her at actual size rather than the size my anxiety had made her.
Renee's cup was still on the side table.
I noticed it and then I didn't look at it again.
Carol stood near the window.
She nodded when we came in.
"Mum," Daniel said.
He sat down in the chair across from her.
I sat beside him.
"We're not here to shout at you."
Patricia looked at him.
Her expression was something I hadn't seen from her before — not the managing composure, not the careful control.
Something underneath all of that.
Something tired.
"I know," she said.
"Then I need you to help me understand," he said.
"Why Renee?
Why now?
Why, after I called you and told you clearly — why did you meet her the next day?"
Patricia looked at her hands.
"Because she asked me to."
"That's not enough."
"I know." She looked up.
"Daniel, I have been — I have been holding onto something for a very long time.
Something I didn't know how to put down.
And when Cass got pregnant and everything became real and the baby was coming—" She stopped.
Started again.
"It felt like a door closing.
On something I was still standing in."
"She is not a replacement," I said quietly.
"And our daughter is not a replacement.
And this baby does not belong to a grief that happened before I existed."
Patricia looked at me.
Directly.
No management in it.
"I know," she said.
"I know that.
And I am — I am sorry, Cassandra.
For the nursery.
For the keys.
For—" Her voice caught.
"For falling.
For what happened.
I am sorry that you fell."
Not *for the accident.* Not *for the incident.*
For what happened.
I noticed that.
"Thank you," I said.
Carol spoke from the window.
"Mum.
You need to let Renee go.
Properly.
Not because we're asking you to.
Because carrying that grief the way you've been carrying it is hurting everyone in this room, and I think it's been hurting you too."
Patricia looked at her daughter for a long moment.
Then she nodded, very slowly, the way people nod when they are agreeing to something they already know is true but have been avoiding.
"There's one more thing," Daniel said.
May you like
Patricia waited.
"You need to tell me about the yellow blanket."