Spotlight

Chapter 9: What Paul Finally Said

I told Renee to arrange the meeting.

She didn't like it.

She said she would sit in the corner and that Paul could say what he had to say with her present or not at all.

I told her that was acceptable.

He came the following afternoon.

He had not dressed carefully this time.

He wore a plain dark jacket.

No tie.

He looked like a man who had been sleeping badly, which I suspected was true.

He sat in the chair Colton had used.

He looked at Renee briefly, then at me.

"Thank you for seeing me," he said.

I didn't answer that.

"I want to tell you about Helen," he said.

"Not what I know legally.

What I know personally.

Because you found her letter and you should know who she was."

Renee had her pen.

She didn't write anything yet.

"I was twenty-four when I married Helen," Paul said.

"I was different then, or I told myself I was.

I thought I could manage my mother.

I thought Helen was strong enough to handle the family." He looked at the floor.

"I was wrong on both counts.

By the time I understood what was happening, it had already been happening for months.

And by the time I understood that my mother was dangerous, I had already told Helen that she needed to adjust.

That she needed to try harder.

That she needed to understand how my family worked." He stopped.

"I told her the same things I told you."

The room didn't move.

"When she filed the report, I was angry at her.

I want you to know that.

I was actually angry at her.

Because I thought she was going to ruin everything." He shook his head slowly.

"My father told me not to worry about it.

He told me it would be handled.

I didn't ask how.

I told myself it was better not to ask." He looked up at me.

"That was the choice I made.

I want to say it clearly.

I made a choice."

"You knew Fitch was going to close it," I said.

"I knew something was going to make it go away.

I didn't know his name.

I didn't know the details.

But I knew the shape of it." He paused.

"And then Helen died.

And I told myself it was an accident.

I needed it to be an accident."

Renee wrote something small and quiet on her pad.

"Was it?" I asked.

Paul looked at me for a long moment.

"I don't know.

I have asked myself that question every day for nine years.

I don't know." His voice was careful and very low.

"But I know that if I had acted differently, she might still be alive to answer it herself.

I know that much."

It was the truest thing I had ever heard him say.

It was possibly the truest thing he had ever said in his life.

"Why are you telling me this?" I asked.

"Now.

After everything."

"Because you found her letter.

And she deserved someone to know." He folded his hands.

"And because I have been a coward about everything that matters my entire adult life.

And you dragged yourself across a kitchen floor in the rain.

And I think I am finally—" He stopped.

Started again.

"I think I am finally ashamed enough to tell the truth."

He reached into the inside pocket of his jacket and placed a small key on the edge of the bed.

It was an ordinary key.

The kind that opens a padlock or a small lockbox.

"Helen kept a second record," he said.

"A physical one.

I found it after she died and I hid it.

I told myself I was protecting the family.

I told myself it was better if nobody found it." He looked at the key.

"It's in a storage unit in my name.

Locker forty-four.

The address is on the tag." He stood up.

"Give it to Colton."

He walked to the door.

His hand rested on the frame for a moment.

"Paul." My voice stopped him.

He turned.

"The women she named in the letter," I said.

"Sandra, Ruth, Margaret.

Did you know about them?"

"Sandra," he said quietly.

"I knew about Sandra.

I was there." He looked at the hallway rather than at me.

"I was twenty-two.

I didn't understand what I was watching.

Or I didn't want to." He pushed the door open.

"That's the same thing, isn't it."

He walked out.

Renee picked up the key with a tissue.

She turned it over in her fingers.

"I'll call Colton right now."

"Do that," I said.

I lay back against the pillow.

Through the window the light was going amber at the edges.

The yellow plant on the sill had two new leaves that hadn't been there yesterday.

Mrs.

Young must have watered it again during visiting hours while I was at the station.

Colton retrieved Helen's second record from the storage unit that evening.

He called me at nine.

"It's extensive," he said.

"Photographs.

Dated entries.

A log of every incident going back fourteen months.

Names, times, what was said.

She was methodical." A pause.

"Clara, there's also a formal witness statement in here.

Someone who saw what happened to Helen the night she died.

A neighbor.

She was afraid to come forward at the time." His voice was steady but something underneath it was not.

"She's eighty-one years old now.

She's been waiting to tell someone for nine years."

I closed my eyes.

Helen had not been alone.

Not entirely.

Someone had seen and had been too frightened then and had carried it for nine years and had waited.

The way good people sometimes wait when they are afraid.

The way waiting costs them something they never get back.

"Get her statement," I said.

"Already arranged," Colton said.

"Tomorrow morning."

"And Colton." I opened my eyes.

"Thank you.

For not letting it stay closed."

A pause on his end.

May you like

Brief.

"Thank you for opening the door," he said.

Related Stories

Other posts