Spotlight

Chapter 3: What Helen Left Behind

My attorney's name was Renee Marsh.

She had handled my employment contracts for three years before she ever had to handle anything like this.

She was not the kind of woman who reacted visibly to things.

But when I held up the photograph from inside the folder, she set her pen down.

"Where did that come from?" she asked.

"It was inside the folder.

Second page.

Behind Diane's name."

Renee crossed the room and stood beside the bed.

She looked at the photograph for a long moment without speaking.

The woman in it was younger than me.

Dark hair.

A wide, careful smile.

She was standing in front of what looked like the same house I had lived in for four years.

The Bennett family home.

"Paul said her name was Helen," I said.

"He said she was his first wife."

Renee looked at me.

"Paul was married before you?"

"Apparently."

"Did you know that when you married him?"

"No." I set the photograph down on the sheet.

"I had no idea."

Renee picked up the case file beneath the photograph.

She read slowly.

I watched her face.

It didn't stay still.

"Clara." She turned the file toward me.

"This is a police report.

Filed eleven years ago.

The complainant's name is Helen Marsh — no relation to me.

The responding officer documented injuries consistent with @buse.

The file was closed six weeks later.

Marked inconclusive."

"Inconclusive," I repeated.

"Insufficient evidence.

That was the finding." She set the file on the bed.

"Or that's what someone wrote."

I looked at the closed stamp at the bottom of the page.

The ink was slightly smudged.

The kind of smudge that happens when something is signed in a hurry, or when someone doesn't want to be in the room any longer than necessary.

"Where is Helen now?" I asked.

Renee didn't answer immediately.

She turned back to the folder and lifted a third page from beneath the case file.

It was a death certificate.

Helen Marie Marsh.

Age twenty-six.

Cause of death listed as accidental fall.

Date: nine years ago.

Fourteen months after the police report was closed.

The room was very quiet.

"An accidental fall," I said.

"That's what it says."

My phone was still in my hand from Paul's call.

I looked at it.

He hadn't called back.

He was waiting to find out what I would do.

"He knew," I said.

"Paul knew about this file.

That's why he called.

That's why he was afraid.

He wasn't worried about Diane.

He was worried about Helen."

Renee sat down in the chair beside the bed.

She folded her hands.

That was not a thing she normally did.

"Clara, I need you to listen to me carefully.

What is in this folder is not just evidence for a domestic @buse case.

If what I'm reading is accurate, this could involve a great deal more than what happened to you in that kitchen." She paused.

"I need to make a call.

There is someone I want you to speak with.

A detective.

His name is Ray Colton.

He handles cases that were closed too early."

"You think Helen's case was closed too early."

Renee looked at the death certificate again.

Then she looked at me.

"I think someone made sure it was."

My leg throbbed beneath the hospital sheet.

The same leg Diane had br*ken with a rolling pin in a kitchen while her son watched.

The same family.

The same house.

A different woman lying helpless on the floor eleven years before I did.

Helen had not made it to a neighbor's porch.

I pressed my palm flat against the folder.

"Make the call," I said.

Renee nodded and stepped out of the room.

Through the window in the door I watched her put her phone to her ear.

She turned away.

Her shoulders dropped slightly, the way a person's do when the other line picks up and they know the conversation is going to be hard.

My phone buzzed.

A text from Paul.

*Clara.

Answer me.

We can fix this quietly.

Nobody has to know.*

I turned the phone face-down on the sheet.

Nobody has to know.

I thought about Helen standing in front of that house, smiling at whoever was behind the camera.

I thought about a police report stamped inconclusive.

I thought about a death certificate that said accidental fall and a date fourteen months later.

Renee came back through the door.

She sat down.

She put her phone away.

"Ray Colton will be here tomorrow morning," she said.

"Eight o'clock."

I nodded.

"There's one more thing." She reached into the folder and removed a small envelope from the very back.

It had not been opened.

My name was not on it.

But it had been placed there deliberately, inside the folder, beneath everything else.

As though someone had wanted it found last.

Written on the front in careful handwriting were two words.

*For whoever.*

I looked at Renee.

She looked at me.

"I didn't open it," she said.

"It was sealed when I received the folder.

I think it was meant to be opened by the person who needed it most."

I took the envelope from her hand.

My fingers didn't shake.

But I did not open it yet.

Something told me I needed to wait.

That whatever was inside would change the direction of everything that came next.

And I was not quite ready for the direction to change again.

Not until tomorrow.

Not until Ray Colton sat across from me and told me what he already suspected about Helen's accidental fall.

I slid the envelope beneath my pillow.

Renee watched me do it.

She didn't say anything.

She understood.

Outside the window, the sky had gone gray.

Visiting hours would end in forty minutes.

Somewhere across the city, Paul Bennett was sitting in a room waiting for his phone to ring.

May you like

It wasn't going to ring.

Not tonight.

Related Stories

Other posts