Spotlight

Chapter 6: The Day She Almost Took Evelyn

Grace read the temporary order outside Diane’s house.

“She cannot take Evelyn tonight,” she said.

“But the judge can decide tomorrow whether to place her with Diane during the investigation.”

My knees weakened.

Ben reached for me.

“I won’t let that happen.”

I moved away.

“You already let it begin.”

“I made one unforgivable mistake.”

“You put our clothes in trash bags.”

His face folded.

“I know.”

“No, Ben.

You know the sentence.

You do not know what it felt like to hold our baby and see her father’s back.”

He lowered his hands.

“Tell me what to do.”

“Tell the truth tomorrow, even if it costs you your mother.”

At court, Diane sat beside Dr.

Cole and an attorney named Mr.

Voss.

A large photograph of my hospital room rested on their table.

Mr.

Voss held it up.

“This shows the child’s mother collapsed during an emotional confrontation.”

“I had given birth three days earlier,” I said.

“You also denied the child’s legal father access.”

“He ordered us out of our home.”

Ben stood.

“That is true.”

Mr.

Voss looked at him.

“Mr.

Mercer, did your wife deceive you about the child’s parentage?”

“No.”

“You accused her of doing so.”

“I was wrong.”

“Did she fall after you spoke to her?”

“Yes, because I told her a secret my mother had hidden.”

Diane’s fingers tightened around her handbag.

The judge looked at her.

“Mrs.

Mercer, did you know about the possible sample substitution?”

“I knew Thomas had preserved a sample.

I did not arrange its use.”

Grace placed the authorization page on the evidence stand.

“Is that your signature?”

“It resembles mine.”

“Is it yours?”

“I cannot be sure.”

Mom rose from the back row.

“She was sure at my front door.”

Mr.

Voss objected, but Grace lifted a small memory card.

“My client’s mother has a doorbell camera.

It recorded the conversation after the letter was opened.”

The recording filled the courtroom.

Diane’s voice came clearly: I suspected the clinic might have followed my request.

Diane stood.

“That was taken out of context.”

The judge ordered her to sit.

Mr.

Voss handed over my hospital record.

“The mother also required evaluation for acute emotional distress.”

The words blurred on the page.

Diane leaned close as she passed our table.

“You will lose her before lunch,” she whispered.

My breath stopped.

I grabbed Grace’s sleeve.

“I can’t do this.”

Mom came around the rail and held my face between her hands.

“Look at me,” she said.

“You brought Evelyn home when everyone expected you to break.

You are not leaving without speaking.”

“I’m so tired, Mom.”

“Then speak tired.

But speak.”

I wiped my cheeks and returned to the witness chair.

“Mrs.

Mercer,” Grace said, “why did you refuse Diane access to Evelyn?”

“Because she looked at my newborn child and saw money.”

Dr.

Cole suddenly stood.

“That is enough.”

Every face turned toward him.

Diane hissed, “Sit down.”

“No,” he said.

“You promised this would never reach court.”

Mr.

Voss grabbed his arm.

“Do not say another word.”

Dr.

Cole pulled free.

“Diane is going to blame me for all of it.”

“She already has,” Grace said.

“The petition calls the substitution a clinic decision.”

Dr.

Cole stared at Diane.

“You said Thomas wanted this.”

“He did.”

“You forged his consent.”

The judge ordered the doors closed.

Dr.

Cole reached inside his jacket and removed a small digital recorder.

“I kept this because I knew one day she would deny everything,” he said.

Diane lunged across the table.

A court officer caught her wrist before she reached it.

Dr.

Cole placed the recorder in Grace’s hand.

May you like

“Play the conversation from six years ago,” he said.

“Then ask Diane what she planned to do with the baby.”

Related Stories

Other posts