Chapter 3: The Father Named on the Page

“Thomas Mercer,” Ben said.
His father’s name seemed to hang between us.
Mom tightened her arms around Evelyn.
“That cannot be right.”
Ben pushed the letter toward me.
“It says the clinic found an irregularity in the donor records.
A preserved sample registered to my father may have been used during our treatment.”
I looked at Diane.
“You knew Thomas’s sample existed?”
“It was stored before his cancer treatment,” she said.
“He wanted another child.”
“He wanted another child with you,” Ben replied.
“Not with my wife.”
Diane lifted her chin.
“Thomas wanted his family line protected.”
“I was carrying Ben’s child,” I said.
“You had no right to make that decision.”
“You signed consent forms.”
“For Ben’s sample or an anonymous donor we both approved.
Not my father-in-law.”
Ben unfolded the second page.
His finger stopped beside a handwritten note.
“‘Substitution authorized by D.
Mercer.’” He looked up.
“That is your signature.”
Diane reached for the letter, but he pulled it away.
“You had just one viable sample,” she said.
“Dr.
Cole told me it was too weak.
I did what was necessary.”
“Necessary for whom?” I asked.
“For this family.”
“You left that family’s baby outside a hospital room.”
Her mouth tightened.
“I was shocked.”
“You called Evelyn a disappointment.”
“And Ben threw us out,” I said.
“Did you tell him to do that too?”
Ben lowered his eyes.
“Answer me,” I demanded.
Diane folded her arms.
“I told him you had probably betrayed him.
I was trying to make sense of what I saw.”
“You already knew about the substitution,” Ben said.
“You knew she hadn’t betrayed me.”
“I suspected the clinic might have followed my request.
I didn’t know for certain.”
Ben held up the letter.
“You let me accuse my wife while you stood beside me.”
Evelyn began to cry.
Mom carried her into the living room, but Diane moved toward them.
“Let me see the birthmark.”
I blocked the doorway.
“You will not touch her.”
“She is Thomas’s daughter.”
“She is my daughter.”
“And if that letter is accurate,” Diane said, “she may be entitled to part of Thomas’s estate.”
Ben stared at her.
“This is about money?”
“It is about what Thomas intended.”
“Thomas left everything in trust,” Ben said.
“You control that trust.”
Diane’s silence answered him.
I took the letter from Ben.
A paragraph near the bottom recommended immediate independent DNA testing and legal advice.
“I’m having the test done,” I said.
Diane’s hand closed over my wrist.
“Think carefully.”
I pulled away.
“Do not threaten me in my mother’s house.”
“You don’t understand what a test could start.
Thomas’s estate attorneys will become involved.
The clinic will protect itself.
Your medical history will be examined.”
“What does my medical history have to do with your forgery?”
“If you turn Evelyn into evidence, strangers may decide where she belongs.”
Mom returned and opened the front door.
“Leave,” she said.
Diane gave me one last look.
“If you force this into court, I will prove Evelyn belongs with the Mercer family.”
Ben’s face hardened.
“She is already with her family.”
Diane stepped onto the porch.
“Then you had better decide which side of that family you’re on.”
Ben flinched as the door shut.
I placed the letter against his chest.
“You have one chance to tell me everything.”
“I just did.”
“No.
You told me why you doubted Evelyn.
You haven’t told me why your mother believes she can take her.”
Ben looked through the window at Diane waiting beside her car.
May you like
“Because my father’s trust contains a guardianship clause,” he said.
“And Mom helped write it.”