Spotlight

Chapter 5: Patrick

I had not spoken to Patrick Teague in nine years.

Not since the Christmas of 2015, when something had happened at Cormac's parents' house that nobody in the family had ever properly addressed and everyone had agreed, without discussion, to simply move past.

Or try to.

Patrick was forty-two.

He'd lived in Edinburgh for the last six years.

He worked in architectural salvage, which suited him — quiet, careful work, handling things other people had let go of.

He came back for the funeral.

He stood at the back of the church in a dark coat and I had not been able to look at him directly because his face was the closest thing to Cormac's face I had ever seen, and I was barely managing as it was.

He had not come to the reception afterward.

I'd noticed.

I hadn't had the capacity to feel anything about it at the time.

"Patrick," I said.

"Yes."

"You've been in love with Cormac's brother."

"Since I was about twenty-six," Vivien said.

"Yes."

"And Cormac knew."

"Cormac figured it out around 2004.

He never said anything directly to me until 2008, and even then he only said it once." She looked down at her hands.

"He said, *I know about you and Patrick.

I'm not angry.

I just need to know it's not still happening.*"

"Was it?"

"No.

It had never — it had never really started.

Not properly." She exhaled.

"We spent one evening together, in 2003, in October.

We talked.

We admitted it.

And then Patrick said he couldn't do it to Cormac, and I agreed, and that was that." She paused.

"That was the same week Cormac and I ended.

And then about eighteen months later you and Cormac got together and I thought — right, that's the shape of it then.

That's how it goes."

I sat very still.

"You've been in love with Patrick for almost twenty years," I said.

"And the two of you never — "

"Never."

"Because of Cormac."

"Because of Cormac.

And then because of you." She said it without self-pity, just as a plain fact.

"Because you were my best friend and I was not going to bring something into your marriage that would damage it.

Even something that was nothing to do with your marriage."

I thought about all the years.

All the Christmases.

All the times Patrick had been in the same room and I had never once thought to look at the two of them at the same moment.

"Christmas 2015," I said.

Vivien's jaw tightened slightly.

"What actually happened that Christmas," I said.

"Nobody ever told me.

Cormac said it was nothing.

His mother said it was nothing.

Patrick left before dessert and didn't come back for two years."

"It wasn't nothing."

"I know it wasn't nothing."

She was quiet for a moment.

The water moved.

The dog was gone.

"His mother found some old messages on Patrick's phone," Vivien said.

"From 2003.

She'd borrowed it to make a call.

She went looking, the way she sometimes did." A pause.

"She confronted him in the kitchen.

She was not quiet about it.

Cormac heard.

He came in and ended it before it became something it couldn't come back from." She stopped.

"His mother never liked me after that.

You may have noticed."

I had noticed.

I'd put it down to the ordinary friction of that family, the complicated undercurrent that ran through the Teagues the way it ran through most families if you looked closely enough.

I'd never known what it was connected to.

"Where is Patrick now?" I asked.

"Edinburgh.

Still." She hesitated.

"He called me after Cormac d*ed.

He called to ask if I was all right.

He knew — he knew how much Cormac meant to me, in a different way, in his own way." Her voice dropped slightly.

"We've spoken a few times since November.

On the phone."

Something shifted in my chest.

Not badly.

Just shifted.

"Does he know you're telling me this?"

"He knows I was going to.

He said—" she stopped.

"What did he say?"

Vivien looked at me steadily.

"He said he thought you deserved to know the whole truth.

Even the parts that were uncomfortable.

He said you'd always been able to hold difficult things."

Cormac used to say the same.

Almost exactly the same words.

The brothers were very alike in ways that had nothing to do with their faces.

"There's one more thing," Vivien said.

"One thing that's mine to tell you, not Cormac's."

My stomach pulled tight.

"Go on."

"I love you," she said simply.

"You are the person I have loved longest in my life.

Everything I kept — I kept because losing you was not something I could survive.

I want you to know that the secret was never about protecting myself from your anger.

It was about protecting what we had." She stopped.

"If that was wrong, I understand.

But I need you to know what it was."

The wind picked up off the water.

Somewhere behind us, inside the house, something shifted — a door, a curtain, the small sounds of a rented place settling.

I looked at my best friend of thirty-seven years.

"I need to go for a walk," I said.

"On my own.

Just for a bit."

She nodded.

She didn't reach for me.

She understood exactly what that meant.

I stood up, tucked the letter into my pocket, and walked down onto the sand.

I walked for a long time along the waterline.

I didn't know yet what I felt.

But somewhere in the middle of all of it — the grief, the strangeness, the vertigo of learning that the shape of your own life was slightly different from the shape you'd believed — there was something unexpected.

There was a small, quiet thing that felt almost like relief.

May you like

I didn't understand it yet.

I kept walking, and I let it sit there, and I didn't try to name it.

Related Stories

Other posts