Spotlight

Chapter 4: Before the Wedding

I read the rest of it.

It took me three attempts because my hands wouldn't stop shaking and twice I had to set the letter down on my knee and look at the water until I could breathe properly again.

Cormac had written four pages.

The first page was about me.

About what he wanted me to do after.

Practical things and impossible things mixed together — make sure the guttering gets checked before winter, please stop eating cereal for dinner when you're sad, let yourself be happy again even if that feels like a betrayal because it isn't, it was never going to be.

He knew me.

He wrote me in that letter like a person who had studied me for eighteen years and wanted me to know I had been seen.

The second page was about what I had meant to him.

I am not going to try to describe that part.

It belongs to me.

The third page was where everything changed.

He wrote: *I need to tell you something about Vivien, and about me, and about the year before we got married.

I'm telling you because I think you deserve to know, and because I think not knowing might be worse than knowing, and because I am a coward who couldn't say it to your face and I am sorry for that.*

I lowered the letter.

"Viv."

She was looking at the water.

"I know."

"He's telling me something happened between you two in 2003."

"Yes."

"Before he and I were together."

"Yes."

"But we all knew each other in 2003," I said.

"The three of us worked at the same place.

I'd known you for fourteen years by then."

"I know."

"He and I didn't get together until 2005." I heard my own voice, oddly steady, like it belonged to someone who was handling this better than I was.

"So you weren't — there was no overlap.

That's what he's saying."

Vivien turned to look at me.

"There was no overlap," she said clearly.

"It was before.

And it was brief.

And it ended.

And I need you to understand that he chose to tell you, Lorna.

He chose it.

That matters."

"How brief?"

She pressed her lips together.

"Three months."

I looked back at the letter.

"He says he ended it."

"He did."

"He says he ended it because he realized he had feelings for me."

Vivien was quiet for a moment.

"That's true."

Something very complicated moved through me.

It wasn't exactly the feeling I'd expected.

It wasn't rage.

It was something more like vertigo — the ground shifting slightly under my feet, not violently, but enough that I had to find a new way to stand on it.

"You were with my husband," I said.

"Before he was your husband."

"Before he was my husband," I repeated.

"And neither of you ever told me."

"No."

"For twenty-one years."

She didn't look away.

"Yes."

I stood up.

I didn't know I was going to until I was already on my feet.

I walked down the two steps onto the sand and stopped there with the letter still in my hand, looking out at the water, which kept moving the way water does regardless of anything that happens on the shore.

Behind me I heard Vivien stand.

"Don't," I said.

"Give me a minute."

She sat back down.

I heard the step creak.

I stood in the sand and tried to put it in order.

2003.

Cormac and Vivien.

Three months.

He ended it.

He fell for me.

He married me.

Vivien stood beside me at the wedding.

She gave a speech.

She cried during the first dance.

She came to Thanksgivings and birthdays and ordinary Sunday afternoons for eighteen more years and she kept his specific mug in the right cabinet and she never said a word.

There was a fourth page.

I unfolded it in the wind.

It said: *I know what you're feeling right now and I'm sorry I'm not there to hold your hand through it.

But I need you to know that Vivien kept this secret to protect you, not herself.

I asked her to.

That part is on me, not on her.

She wanted to tell you more than once.

I talked her out of it every time.

The guilt is mine.

The courage of carrying it, all these years, was hers.*

I read that paragraph four times.

Then I walked back to the steps and sat down.

"He said the decision to keep it secret was his," I said.

"That he talked you out of telling me."

"Every time," she said quietly.

"The last time was in 2019."

"You tried to tell me in 2019."

"I drove to your house.

I sat outside for forty minutes.

And then Cormac came outside to check the bins and saw my car and came over and knocked on my window." She paused.

"He knew.

He always knew when I was close to it."

The wind moved along the beach.

A dog ran past us in the distance, chasing something in the surf.

"Why did he want to keep it from me?" I asked.

"All those years.

What was he afraid of?"

Vivien was quiet for a long moment.

"He was afraid," she said carefully, "that you would think the life you'd had together was built on something false.

And he didn't believe it was.

He believed it was built on what came after." She paused.

"But there's something else.

Something I need to tell you that he left out of the letter."

I turned to look at her.

"He left it out on purpose," she said.

"Because he thought it was mine to tell, not his."

Her hands were shaking again.

The same shaking from yesterday on the lounger, the same shaking I'd watched from four feet away and not understood.

"Viv," I said slowly.

"What did he leave out?"

She closed her eyes.

"The reason it ended so quickly," she said, "wasn't just that he had feelings for you."

She opened her eyes.

"It ended because I ended it.

Because I was already in love with someone else.

Someone I'd been in love with for a very long time." She stopped.

"Someone who was in love with me too, but neither of us had ever said it."

I stared at her.

"His name," Vivien said, "is Patrick."

I went perfectly still.

May you like

Patrick Teague.

Cormac's younger brother.

Related Stories

Other posts