Chapter 8: What He Had to Say Out Loud

The deposition was scheduled for a Thursday morning, three weeks after the filing.
It was held in a conference room on the fourteenth floor of a building downtown.
Round table.
Pale carpet.
A court reporter with a small machine set up at one end.
David Holt on one side.
Claire on the other.
Ethan across from me.
He looked like he hadn't slept well.
His shirt was pressed, but there was something careful and effortful about the way he was holding himself together, like a person aware of being watched.
I had fed my son at five-thirty that morning.
Nina was at Claire's house with him.
I had kissed his forehead before I left.
Claire opened her folder.
"Mr.
Walker," she said.
"For the record, I'd like to begin with the credit card."
Holt leaned forward.
"My client is prepared to address the financial disclosures."
"Good." Claire slid a copy of the statement across the table.
"This account was opened eight months ago.
The primary cardholder is Ethan R.
Walker.
My client had no knowledge of this account.
Can you confirm that's accurate?"
Ethan looked at Holt.
Holt gave a small nod.
"Yes," Ethan said.
"Can you tell me the purpose of this account?"
A pause.
"Personal expenses."
"Personal expenses." Claire made a note.
"Can you describe the nature of the hotel charges on this statement?
Specifically, the three Friday-night charges at the Ellison Inn, approximately forty miles from your marital home."
David Holt put a hand on the table.
"My client isn't required to —"
"Your client is here for financial disclosure," Claire said pleasantly.
"These charges are marital assets in question.
He is, in fact, required."
Another look passed between Ethan and his attorney.
"They were personal," Ethan said.
"Personal with whom?"
The court reporter's fingers moved.
Ethan's jaw tightened.
"With Lydia Marsh."
The room was quiet except for the soft mechanical sound of the reporter's machine.
"And the Scottsdale trip," Claire said.
"The weekend of the fourteenth.
You were listed on the reservation your parents made.
Can you confirm whether Lydia Marsh was the plus-one on that reservation?"
Holt spoke.
"We're prepared to stipulate that Ms.
Marsh was present on the Scottsdale trip."
"I'd like your client to confirm it."
A long pause.
"Yes," Ethan said.
"She was there."
I had known.
I had known since Claire showed me the loyalty card statement.
But hearing it in that room, spoken for the record, in front of the court reporter and the pale carpet and the morning light coming through the window — it landed differently.
It landed the way things land when they stop being suspected and become simply true.
"On the weekend of the fourteenth," Claire said, "your wife was admitted to St.
Carver Hospital at four-seventeen in the morning in active labor.
She gave birth at three-forty-six the following morning.
She was alone for the duration, except for personal friends." She looked at him steadily.
"You were in Scottsdale with another woman."
Holt started to speak.
"I'm not asking a question," Claire said.
"I'm establishing a record."
Ethan looked at me then.
Directly.
For the first time since we had sat down.
"I'm sorry," he said.
Not the managed line from Holt's email.
Something rawer.
It came out like something he hadn't meant to say, or had meant to say differently.
"I know," I said.
It wasn't forgiveness.
It wasn't softness.
It was just acknowledgment — that the word had been spoken, in a room where it was recorded, and that I had heard it, and that it was real, and that it was not enough, and that we both knew that.
Holt called for a short break.
In the hallway, while Ethan and Holt spoke quietly near the elevator, Claire turned to me.
"The cash withdrawals," she said.
"He's agreed to account for them fully.
Holt confirmed during the break."
"What were they for?"
"Gifts.
Dinners.
Two of them were deposits on a rental property." She held my eyes.
"He was planning to move her into it."
I thought about the cloud-print onesies.
Folded on a Sunday afternoon, both of us home, the apartment quiet.
"When?" I asked.
"The lease was to start in six weeks." She gave me a moment.
"From now."
Six weeks from the filing.
Six weeks from the day I walked out of that house with my son asleep against my chest.
"He wanted me gone," I said.
"The financial picture suggests he was managing toward a specific outcome, yes."
I looked down the hallway.
Ethan was standing with his back to me.
His shoulders were curved in a way I didn't recognize.
"What about Denise?" I asked.
Claire almost smiled.
"Her call to you last night is being reviewed," she said.
"Attempting to discourage legal counsel by referencing judicial relationships constitutes potential misconduct.
I've forwarded the recording."
"Forwarded to whom?"
"The county bar oversight board." She tucked a page back into her folder.
May you like
"And the three judges she mentioned.
As a courtesy."