Chapter 3: Everything She Already Knew

Claire set her notepad on the kitchen table between us after I ended the call.
Four pages.
Both sides.
"How long have you been keeping notes?" I asked.
"Since the night you showed up at my door." She tapped the top of the first page.
"Forty weeks pregnant, no hospital bag, no car, no plan.
That's a record, Madison.
Not just of what happened tonight.
Of everything."
I looked at the pages.
Her handwriting was small and precise — dates, times, direct quotes.
Things I had told her over the past two years that I had already half-forgotten.
The dinner where Ethan told me my salary was "supplemental." The weekend he took his parents to a baseball game and told me it was a work event.
The prenatal appointment he missed because his mother needed help choosing tile for her bathroom renovation.
"He's going to say I abandoned the marital home," I said.
"He can say that." Claire turned the notepad toward me.
"But you left because you were in active labor with no transportation and no support.
I picked you up.
Nina was here when you arrived.
The hospital has your admission time.
His phone records will show he was in Arizona." She folded her hands.
"He built the case against himself.
We're just filing it properly."
My son made a small sound against my shoulder.
I shifted him slightly without thinking.
"Ethan's going to call his father next," I said.
"Then his father is going to call their attorney."
"Probably already happened." Claire didn't look worried.
"Let them call."
"His mother is the one who scares me."
Claire picked up her pen.
"Tell me why."
I thought about Denise Walker.
The way she had smiled at our wedding reception and told me, quietly, near the bar, that Ethan had always had difficulty with needy women.
The way she referred to my pregnancy as "the situation" for the first four months.
The way she had honked that horn twice from the driveway while I stood barefoot in my own hallway on the morning my son was born.
"She has money," I said.
"Real money.
The kind that buys patience."
"So do her choices," Claire said.
She wrote something at the bottom of the fourth page and circled it twice.
"And so does her son's phone, which has been sending and receiving messages to a number I don't recognize for the past six weeks."
I went still.
"What?"
"You forwarded me his phone bill two months ago.
You thought there was a billing error." Claire slid the notepad across the table.
At the bottom, circled in blue ink, was a phone number I didn't recognize.
Beneath it, a single notation: *47 calls.
31 texts.
Began same week Scottsdale trip was booked.*
The room was very quiet.
My son's breathing was slow and even against my collarbone.
"Who is it?" I asked.
"I don't know yet," Claire said.
"But I think we need to find out before Ethan does."
She reached across the table and picked up her phone.
She dialed without explaining who she was calling.
After two rings, someone answered.
"It's me," Claire said.
"I need you to run a number."
She read it out carefully, digit by digit.
Then she looked at me across the table, and something in her expression changed — not alarm exactly, but the particular stillness of a person who has just recognized something they were not expecting.
"Say that again," she said into the phone.
She listened.
She nodded once.
Then she ended the call and set the phone down without looking at it.
"Madison," she said.
May you like
"How well do you know Ethan's coworker?
The one named Lydia?"