Spotlight

Chapter 4: What Gareth Knew

I read the message three times.

David watched me read it.

He didn't say anything.

"He knows she's here," I said.

"Yes."

"He's been watching."

"Or someone told him." David set the phone on the hall table.

"Natty, we need to think carefully about what we do next.

If this is who we think it is—"

"It's him." I looked up.

"The ring.

The cedar smell.

The papers.

It's Gareth."

David was quiet for a moment.

Then: "We can't go to the police with a text from an unknown number and a homeless woman's fragmented memories.

He'll deny everything.

He has lawyers.

He has connections.

We need more."

"I know."

"So what do we do?"

I looked back up the stairs toward the guest room.

Mae was still up there, sitting in that armchair, holding twenty-three years of someone else's silence in her body.

"We find the papers," I said.

My father had been meticulous.

Every document, every contract, every letter — he kept physical copies.

He had a system.

I had always known that.

What I hadn't known, until I was nineteen and cleaning out a storage unit my mother had rented before she d*ed — before I thought she d*ed — was that he had a secondary filing location.

A solicitor's office in a town forty minutes north.

A man named Aldous Fenn who had handled my father's private affairs separately from the business.

I had visited once, years ago, and found nothing relevant.

But I had been looking for a will, not for evidence of fraud.

I called the office when it opened at nine.

The receptionist told me Mr.

Fenn had retired but that his daughter, Clara, had taken over the practice.

"I need to come in today," I said.

"It's urgent.

It concerns documents my father left in your care approximately twenty-three years ago.

My name is Natalie Harrow.

My maiden name was Natalie Voss."

A pause.

"Miss Voss," Clara said carefully, coming onto the line herself.

"I was wondering when you might call."

I gripped the phone tighter.

"You were expecting me?"

"My father left me a sealed envelope with your name on it.

He said I was to give it only to you, in person, and only if you came asking about your father's business with a man named Gareth Aldren."

The name hit the air like something physical.

"I'll be there in an hour," I said.

David drove.

I sat in the passenger seat and watched the road and didn't speak.

In the back, Mae had insisted on coming.

I hadn't had the energy to argue.

Halfway there, she spoke from the back seat.

"I remember the solicitor," she said quietly.

"Your father took me once.

Years ago.

He said — he said if anything ever happened to him, that man would know what to do."

I turned around to look at her.

"He knew," I said.

"He knew something might happen."

"He was frightened," Mae said.

"In the last weeks before — before everything.

He was very frightened.

But he wouldn't tell me why.

He said it was safer if I didn't know."

"And Gareth?"

Her hands folded in her lap.

"Gareth smiled too much.

That's what I always thought.

He smiled at everything, even when there was nothing to smile about.

Your father trusted him completely.

I never understood why."

Clara Fenn was in her late forties, precise and calm, with her father's careful eyes.

She led us into a back office and set a sealed manila envelope on the desk between us.

"My father made a note," she said.

"He said your father brought this to him the week before the fire.

He said Gareth Aldren had forged his signature on a property transfer — a large one — and had been siphoning funds from their joint company for several years.

Your father had assembled proof.

Copies of the original documents, a forensic accounting summary, and a signed statement."

My throat was tight.

"Why didn't your father go to the police?"

"He tried.

Two days after your father brought him this envelope, there was a fire." She held my gaze.

"Your family home.

He assumed the original documents were destroyed.

He assumed — everyone assumed — that your mother had also—" She stopped.

Mae was sitting very still beside me.

"She didn't," I said.

Clara looked at Mae for a long moment.

Something moved across her face.

"No," she said softly.

"I can see that."

I opened the envelope.

Inside were twelve pages of documents, a handwritten letter in my father's handwriting, and a photograph I had never seen — my father and Gareth, standing in front of a property I didn't recognize, both smiling, a date stamped in the corner.

Six months before the fire.

At the bottom of the photograph, in my father's handwriting:

*He thinks I don't know yet.

I do.*

I set the photograph down on the desk.

Gareth had known my father was building a case against him.

He had come to the house that morning to stop it.

And when he couldn't — when my father refused — he had made sure the house, the documents, and every witness inside it would be g*ne before nightfall.

Except Mae had run.

And my father had already moved the proof.

I looked up at Clara.

"What do we do with this?"

She had a name already written on a notepad in front of her.

She slid it across the desk.

"My father knew a detective inspector," she said.

"He's retired now, but his former sergeant is still active.

She's been waiting a long time for someone to walk through that door."

Outside, David put his hand over mine on the car door.

"He doesn't know about the envelope," he said quietly.

"Not yet," I said.

My phone buzzed.

A call from Gareth's personal number.

May you like

I stared at the screen until it stopped ringing.

Then I put the envelope in my bag and got in the car.

Related Stories

Other posts