Chapter 6: The Woman Elizabeth Feared

Elizabeth moved toward Vivian.
“You promised never to come near my family.”
“I promised to give you time to tell the truth.”
“You had no right to bring those letters.”
Vivian held the bundle against her chest.
“I raised you.
I have every right to stop you becoming the person who frightened you.”
Daniel pulled out a chair.
“Please tell me what happened.”
Vivian sat beside me.
“Margaret called social services after she saw marks on Elizabeth’s arms.
My brother blamed Margaret when Elizabeth was removed from his home.”
Elizabeth struck the table with her palm.
“He was my father.”
“He was hurting you.”
“He said he was sorry.”
“He said it every week.”
Daniel’s voice softened.
“Why did you blame Grandma?”
Elizabeth looked toward the dark window.
“Because blaming her was easier than admitting my father chose his temper over me.”
Vivian untied the ribbon.
“These are Margaret’s letters.
She wrote every month after Elizabeth came to live with me.”
I opened the first one.
“Why were they never delivered?”
“Elizabeth’s father intercepted several.
When I found them years later, Elizabeth refused to read them.”
“You should have burned them,” Elizabeth said.
Vivian slid one across the table.
“You read this one.
You wrote your answer on the back.”
Daniel read aloud.
“Margaret, one day I’ll have a little girl named Lily.
I’ll give her everything we never had.
You can make us matching wings.”
Elizabeth covered her mouth.
I touched the faded costume.
“That’s how my mother knew Lily’s name.”
Vivian nodded.
“Margaret made the new costume years later.
She hoped Elizabeth would finally tell you about their promise.”
“Instead, she took the trust money,” Daniel said.
Elizabeth faced him.
“I borrowed it.”
“You hid the statements.”
“I would have replaced everything when my company recovered.”
Vivian removed her phone.
“Tell them what you said when I asked about the withdrawals.”
“Put that away.”
Vivian pressed the screen.
Elizabeth’s recorded voice filled the room.
“If you tell Daniel, I’ll say you took the money.
Margaret is gone, and nobody will believe an old woman who lived on a nurse’s pension.”
Daniel stepped away from his wife.
“You threatened Vivian?”
“She recorded me without permission.”
“I recorded you in my own kitchen,” Vivian said.
“After you tried to make me sign a confession.”
Elizabeth’s eyes moved from the phone to the letters.
“I can still explain.”
“Then explain to Lily,” I said.
“Tell her why her mother took money meant for her future.”
“You will not speak to my daughter.”
“She asked me to make her a costume.
I didn’t drag her into this.”
“You opened that trunk in front of her.”
“She found it.”
“And now she’s frightened because all of you care more about old paper than her.”
Daniel’s shoulders dropped.
“She needs both parents to stop lying.”
Elizabeth picked up her bag.
“She needs her mother.”
She rushed from the room.
Daniel followed her into the bank lobby.
“Where are you going?”
“To collect Lily.”
“You’re too upset to drive.”
“Try stopping me.”
Vivian gripped my hand as Daniel ran outside.
Through the glass, we saw Elizabeth climb into her car and pull away.
My phone lit up with a message from an unknown number.
A photograph showed the cedar trunk lying open in my guest room.
The letters and costumes inside had been thrown across the floor.
May you like
Beneath it were six words:
STAY AWAY, OR LILY LOSES YOU.